{ "title": "Contact chaining", "type": "REPORTED", "description": "A secret GCHQ Applied Research presentation describing how the agency's analysts use automated tools to map out a surveillance target's social network — starting with a known email address or phone number, then scoring and ranking every person that target communicates with to identify the most \"suspicious\" or strongly connected contacts, using twelve different relationship types including direct calls, shared locations, timing patterns, equipment sharing and calling profile similarity.", "long_description": "This is a SECRET STRAP1 GCHQ Applied Research presentation on contact chaining, appearing twice in the document — once as slides only and once with presenter notes providing additional operational context. The presentation describes over eight years of research by GCHQ's B17 unit into automated methods for starting with known surveillance targets and expanding outward through their communications data to discover new targets and map social networks.\n\nThe presentation lists five past prototype tools developed over this period and their planned successor: SNAPDRAGON (a computer-to-computer contact chaining tool described in the presenter notes as not having worked as intended), PRIME TIME (a telephony timing analysis tool), CARPAT (a filtering tool that extracts network data surrounding targets from bulk collection), MoaG (a contact chaining tool arising from the 7 July 2005 London bombings investigation, still in regular operational use at time of presentation), SORTING FRIENDS (a telephony contact chaining tool developed by a GCHQ integree at NSA's R62 unit) and CHART BREAKER (the new prototype intended to consolidate lessons from all previous tools).\n\nSORTING FRIENDS receives the most detailed description. It clusters telephone numbers by extrapolating social relationships from communications events across twelve relationship types: direct communication, co-location relationships, timing and sequence patterns, callbacks, similar numbers, equipment sharing, calling profile similarity and five additional unnamed relationship categories. The presenter notes state it was being run on the A24 datamart and that an analyst in SD could run it for large operational projects. The tool was considered a research prototype whose techniques would eventually be incorporated into CHART BREAKER rather than being operationalised independently.\n\nThe presentation identifies four technical problems driving current research. The first is data mart generation — it was no longer feasible to build traditional TNNN data marts for target sets due to growing data volumes, so CONTACT LENS was developed to use scoring to reduce the analytical workload, querying data from Fleximart VLSP repositories. The second is edge scoring — representing complex communications events as weighted graphs where edge scores measure relationship strength between identifiers. The worked example uses fictional @gchq.com email addresses to demonstrate how different relationship types (sender-to-receiver, timing patterns, PSOUP correlations between recipients) are collapsed into numerical edge weights. PSOUP appears as a named correlation technique producing scores between co-recipients of emails. The third is node scoring — using aggregated edge scores to rank non-target identifiers by suspiciousness relative to known targets. The algorithm described distributes weight from targets iteratively along links across multiple hops, not just to first-circle contacts, producing a ranked list of the most significant non-targets. Pre-calculated node-level scores such as spam scores can be incorporated to lower the ranking of known non-intelligence identifiers. The fourth is interactive visualisation — providing multiple views (graph, score lists, textual descriptions), natural language explanations of why scores were assigned, drill-down capability into underlying events, and interactive recalculation when an analyst promotes a non-target to target status.\n\nCHART BREAKER is described as the consolidation prototype built on the Jung Java graph framework, designed to be flexible enough to rapidly test different scoring techniques. It uses CONTACT LENS to query Fleximart VLSP data and visualises results through i2 (a commercial intelligence analysis tool) and MAMBA (an internal GCHQ visualisation platform). The presenter notes indicate the software would likely need to be rewritten for efficiency once the optimal scoring algorithms were determined.\n\nThe document is significant for revealing the mathematical and algorithmic sophistication of GCHQ's social network analysis research — moving beyond simple contact lists to multi-dimensional relationship scoring that combines direct communications, temporal patterns, geographic co-location, equipment sharing and behavioural similarity into unified suspiciousness rankings. The iterative weight distribution algorithm described for node scoring is conceptually similar to Google's PageRank algorithm, applied to identifying intelligence targets rather than ranking web pages. The London bombings origin of MoaG and the NSA collaboration on SORTING FRIENDS confirm these tools were developed in response to real operational requirements and through active Five Eyes research partnerships.", "tags": [ "metadata analysis", "communications network", "graph analysis", "node scoring", "edge scoring", "interactive visualisation", "contact chaining", "GCHQ", "Applied Research", "social network analysis", "telephony analysis", "co-location", "timing analysis", "equipment", "calling profile similarity", "London bombings", "datamart", "target discovery", "SIGDEV" ], "document": { "creator": "GCHQ", "date_created": "", "classification": [ "SECRET", "STRAP 1" ], "dissemination": [], "banner": "SECRET STRAP 1", "genre": "slides", "programs": [ "CARPAT", "PRIME TIME", "SNAPDRAGON", "MoaG", "SORTING FRIENDS", "CHART BREAKER", "MAMBA", "CONTACTLENS", "FLEXIMART", "PSOUP", "IMMINGLE" ], "countries": [], "people": [] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The Intercept", "date_published": "2018-03-01", "title": "How London's 7/7 Bombings Led to \"Unprecedented\" Surveillance Tactics", "link": "https://theintercept.com/2018/03/01/london-7-7-bombings-gchq-nsa-surveillance/", "reporters": [ "Gallagher, Ryan" ], "contributors": [], "doc_source": "https://theintercept.com/document/2018/03/01/contact-chaining-gchq/", "doc_url": "https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4390394/B17-TDB-Knowledge-Sharing.pdf" } ], "pdf_sha256": "c61c6e8686063529fe4eee5affc327a852d0fe6ba922cc324ce8e96433bf2d39", "pages": 20 }