{ "title": "India: Support to Terrorist Attacks in Mumbai", "type": "REPORTED", "description": "A top secret NSA intelligence report on GCHQ's surveillance of Lashkar-e-Taiba technology chief Zarrar Shah before and during the November 2008 Mumbai attacks, documenting how analysis of his internet browsing and viewing habits revealed reconnaissance activity and operational planning against Mumbai targets including the Taj Hotel.", "long_description": "This top secret document summarises the results of a cross-community intelligence effort focused on Zarrar Shah, the technology and communications chief of Lashkar-e-Taiba, in connection with the November 2008 Mumbai attacks that killed 166 people. The document describes how analysis of Shah's internet viewing habits — including his use of Google Earth and Wikimapia — yielded detailed intelligence on operational planning for the attacks, identifying multiple locations in Mumbai including entry points into the Taj Hotel, the Gateway of India, tourist sites, dams, power plants, and potential boat landing locations.\n\nThe document's most significant disclosure is the description of behavioural analysis of internet viewing habits as a \"new capability\" at the time, one that in this case produced what the document describes as a complete operations plan for the attacks. The capability apparently involved real-time or near-real-time access to Shah's browsing activity — GCHQ documents cited in the New York Times reporting describe the intelligence haul as \"unprecedented real-time active access in place.\" The document also notes that detailed analysis of Shah's complete viewing history identified additional areas of interest that may be under threat of future attacks, with specifics redacted.\n\nThe document is notable for what it implicitly reveals about the failure of pre-attack intelligence sharing: despite GCHQ having substantial visibility into Shah's online activity including his reconnaissance of Mumbai targets, the intelligence was not shared with Indian authorities in time to prevent the attacks. The NYT/ProPublica/Frontline reporting based on this and related documents describes this as one of the most devastating intelligence near-misses in modern counterterrorism history, with British, Indian and American agencies each holding pieces of the puzzle that were never assembled until after the killing began.", "tags": [], "document": { "creator": "NSA", "date_created": "", "classification": [ "TOP SECRET", "SI" ], "dissemination": [ "REL TO USA, FVEY" ], "banner": "TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR//", "genre": "report", "programs": [], "countries": [ "India" ], "people": [ "Shah, Zarrar" ] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The New York Times", "date_published": "2014-12-21", "title": "In 2008 Mumbai Attacks, Piles of Spy Data, but an Uncompleted Puzzle", "link": "https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/22/world/asia/in-2008-mumbai-attacks-piles-of-spy-data-but-an-uncompleted-puzzle.html", "reporters": [ "Glanz, James", "Rotella, Sebastian", "Sanger, David E." ], "contributors": [ "Lehren, Andrew W.", "Walsh, Declan", "Larson, Jeff", "Jennings, Tom", "Peevey, Anna Belle" ] }, { "publisher": "ProPublica", "date_published": "2014-12-21", "title": "In 2008 Mumbai Attacks, Piles of Spy Data, But an Uncompleted Puzzle", "link": "https://www.propublica.org/article/mumbai-attack-data-an-uncompleted-puzzle", "reporters": [ "Rotella, Sebastian" ], "contributors": [ "Larson, Jeff", "Jennings, Tom", "Peevey, Anna Belle", "Glanz, James", "Sanger, David E.", "Lehren, Andrew W.", "Walsh, Declan" ] }, { "publisher": "PBS", "date_published": "2014-12-21", "title": "In 2008 Mumbai Attacks, Piles of Spy Data, but an Uncompleted Puzzle", "link": "http://apps.frontline.org/web-of-terror/", "reporters": [ "Jennings, Tom", "Peevey, Anna Belle", "Nieling, Michael" ], "contributors": [ "Walker, Chris", "Blevins, Grace", "Akinola, Fola", "Albaugh, Jake", "Rasquin, Julie", "Yuen, Mindy", "Hubley, Hillary", "Gulliver, Eric", "Audette, Kenzie" ] } ], "pdf_sha256": "304624e9fe5ba8ed2c0928ed57eaa02d1230e6e610857bc3b6b03d1b3da9dd95", "pages": 1 }