{ "title": "Pull Steering Group Minutes", "type": "REPORTED", "description": "A top secret STRAP1 GCHQ PullThrough Steering Group meeting record from February 2008 documenting the approval process for five surveillance and intelligence prototypes including KARMA POLICE — the mass internet browsing profiling system — alongside ORB FINDER for CNE operational relay box identification, SALTY OTTER for cross-media timing analysis, MOOSE MILK for telephone kiosk surveillance, and LIGHTWOOD for email address extraction used by JTRIG.\n", "long_description": "This is the minutes of the 16th PullThrough Steering Group meeting at GCHQ, dated 29 February 2008. The PTSG was the internal body responsible for evaluating analytical prototypes and progressing them through Technology Readiness Levels toward operational deployment. The document is significant primarily because it contains the earliest known internal record of KARMA POLICE being formally considered for development — years before it became the operational mass profiling system described in the September 2015 Intercept reporting.\n\nThe KARMA POLICE entry describes it in its own words as aiming \"to correlate every user visible to passive SIGINT with every website they visit,\" producing either a browsing profile for every visible internet user or a user profile for every visible website. The PTSG approved it for further development, but with a notable caveat: the legalities around collecting content rather than metadata still needed to be resolved. This is an early indication that GCHQ was aware of the legal uncertainties surrounding the programme before it was built and deployed, undercutting later characterisations of the agency's surveillance activities as operating within a clear legal framework.\n\nThe other prototypes considered at the meeting illustrate the breadth of GCHQ's analytical development agenda at the time. A cross-media timing correlation tool called SALTY OTTER was designed to link events across different communication channels — detecting, for example, that a phone call preceded a chat session — a technique with obvious applications for connecting pseudonymous online identities to known targets. A tool called ORB FINDER aimed to reduce the active footprint of computer network exploitation by passively identifying compromised third-party systems suitable for use as routing hops before any active engagement with them. MOOSE MILK applied data mining to detect suspicious patterns in UK public telephone kiosk usage. LIGHTWOOD, already operational within JTRIG, extracted email addresses from intercepted traffic with a sophistication beyond standard pattern matching, with its more sensitive capabilities left undescribed in the minutes.\n\nTaken together the document offers a rare view into the internal bureaucratic process by which GCHQ's most consequential surveillance capabilities moved from prototype to deployment — and into the moment, long before public awareness, when the agency was deciding whether and how to build a system designed to profile the entire visible internet.", "tags": [ "PullThrough Steering Group", "PTSG", "JTRIG", "Computer Network Exploitation", "Technology Readiness Level", "TRL", "cross-media timing", "telephone surveillance", "emails", "Operational Relay Box", "internet profiling", "prototype approval", "analytical development", "passive SIGINT", "legal compliance", "content collection", "every website they visit", "every visible user on the internet" ], "document": { "creator": "GCHQ", "date_created": "2008-02-29", "classification": [ "TOP SECRET", "STRAP 1" ], "dissemination": [], "banner": "TOP SECRET STRAP1", "genre": "report", "programs": [ "MYOFIBRIL", "SALTYOTTER", "PRIMETIME", "KARMAPOLICE", "ORBFINDER", "MOOSEMILK", "LIGHTWOOD", "JTRIG", "MERAPEAK", "MONTEVISTA", "KED" ], "countries": [], "people": [] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The Intercept", "date_published": "2015-09-25", "title": "Profiled: From Radio to Porn, British Spies Track Web Users' Online Identities", "link": "https://theintercept.com/2015/09/25/gchq-radio-porn-spies-track-web-users-online-identities/", "reporters": [ "Gallagher, Ryan" ], "contributors": [], "doc_source": "https://theintercept.com/document/2015/09/25/pull-steering-group-minutes/", "doc_url": "https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/2432296/pull-through-steering-group-minutes.pdf" } ], "pdf_sha256": "1e97b4b72139c05abe25dd1588a1119b91e47e93d25fe3f103118cc158848614", "pages": 3 }