GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 # Supporting HMG's Climate Change Ambitions (...or, "A GCO's tales from Cancun") 27 November – 10 December 2010 [REDACTED] --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Background * International Treaty opened for signature in 1992 as the UNFCCC * Kyoto Protocol agreed in 1997 * Defined first commitment period for certain 'developed' countries (2008-12) - It agreed GHG emissions reductions by % of 1990 levels * Second commitment period needed to include commitments for 'developing' countries (a 'KP2') * 192 countries now party to UNFCCC --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Why include Developing Countries? In 2010...... Top 10 economies (by GDP): 1. USA 2. China 3. Japan 4. India 5. Germany 6. UK 7. Russia 8. France 9. Brazil 10. Italy Top 10 CO2 emitters (one unit = 1,000 tonnes) USA CHINA RUSSIA JAPAN INDIA GERMANY UK CANADA ITALY MEXICO 6,000,000 5,000,000 4,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 1,000,000 0 --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## The Players * UK – negotiates as part of EU and plays a leading role * Major developed countries e.g. USA and Canada * Major developing countries – BASIC (Brazil, South Africa, India, China) * COP hosts (Mexico) * Vulnerable countries – AOSIS, G77 * Other influencers e.g. OPEC --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Opposing views and Sticking Points * Historic responsibility of developed countries * Emissions reductions seen as a way of slowing growth of emerging powers * Money and technology for developing nations for clean energy, adaptation and mitigation (the Green Fund or „Fast-Start“) * Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) * An agreement binding developed and developing countries --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## The road to Cancun * 2007 COP13, Bali: the first time that climate change became a serious intelligence priority – COP13 has to work! * Spring MEF meeting in Paris: our first GCO climate change deployment Some lessons learned! * 2008 COP14, Poznan: not expected to be a significant gathering * 2009 COP15, Copenhagen or bust (it bust!) "The Copenhagen Accord" Our first COP climate change GCO deployment ...a success * 2010 COP16, low ambition, low expectation, but hugely important The talks must get back on track --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## What's the role for intelligence? Political decisions often made in advance * What do governments want? * What will they sign up to? * What are the negotiating positions on broad or specific issues? * What are their red lines? * Views about other countries * Who is aligning with who? * Who is lobbying who? * Who are the spoilers? * Are delegates reporting back and getting fresh instructions? * What are they? --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Customers * No.10 and Cabinet Office * Department for Energy and Climate Change * FCO - Diplomats - SOSFCA's Special Representative * Department for International Development * Treasury * G20 representatives --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Now...where did I put my sombrero? * Why did we decide to send someone to Cancun? - Customers wanted us to be there - High likelihood of relevant, time-sensitive intelligence - First opportunity to show a new ministerial team what we can do * Preparations - Suitable cover within UK delegation - Logistics (kit, rooms, passes, delegate lists, etc) - Introductions with customers - Intelligence requirements - Coordination in HQ * With other teams and SIS * Methodology for delivery * Working patterns * Policy clearance --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Behind the scenes at COP16 cop16 méxico 2010 --- --- ``` Oficinas de Delegaciones Delegations Offices Oficinas de Delegaciones Delegations Offices Sombrero 1244 - 1255 | 1243 - 1200 1144 - 1155 | 1143 - 1100 1044 - 1055 | 1043 - 1000 China ``` --- ``` UNITED KINGDOM ``` --- --- --- --- --- --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Why was Cancun a success? * The talks didn't fail and... * Agreed that emissions should peak at 2°C * Anchored emissions reduction pledges from the Copenhagen Accord * Agreed a system of MRV * Green Fund established * Agreed to reduce emissions from deforestation * Set up mechanisms for developed countries to access low carbon technology --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## The future * Continue to support negotiations, but... - How are South Africa approaching COP17? - Who is backing Qatar and South Korea in their bids for COP18? - A KP2 is looking unlikely, but... - ...some kind of multi-stage, bolt on agreement is probably achievable - A low carbon economy through efficiency and new technology could help achieve climate change goals...good for the economy and probably trade --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## UK Customers * Department for Energy and Climate Change - International negotiations - Domestic and European policies (energy efficiency, achieving a low-carbon economy; meeting 2020 obligations) * Foreign and Commonwealth Office - International diplomacy - Secretary of State's Special Envoy * Ministry of Defence - Regional instability - Resource security (water, food, land) * Department for International Development - Overseas aid - Emergency relief * Her Majesty's Treasury - The Green Fund * Department for Business Innovation & Skills - Supporting UK inward/outward investment and international trade - Developing low carbon technologies - Protecting intellectual property --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## New challenges for intelligence * Policy questions Fewer disputing science – climate change happening and almost certainly man-made, so... - Is low carbon ambition driving government and investor decisions in economies? - Is UNFCCC still important or is private capital shifting to low carbon because costs and scarcity of resource make sense? - Are governments making the link between extreme weather and high commodity prices? - Are governments planning for instability or mass migrations caused by water/food scarcity, lack of natural resources and land-use change? * Competing intelligence priorities --- GCHQ SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE COP16 méxico 2010 ## Questions? ``` Sombrero Tequila ```