TOP SECRET STRAP1 # Graph theory in the operational environment [REDACTED] - GCHQ Information & Communications Technology Research (ICTR) © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## What I will cover * Finding operational closed loops: * The reality of target behaviour * The process of looking for closed loops * Some statistics on a large graphs components * A real life example * Cheap and disposable handsets * Catching targets for real * What Donald Rumsfeld taught me about closed loops * Using graphs to visualise and characterise timing relationships in a contact graph © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## What is a closed loop? * A set of (for example) phones that communicate only amongst themselves as a means of communications security * This is generally speaking too loose a definition for practical purposes © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Tightening up the definition of a closed loop * A component on three or more nodes that is neither the giant component nor a tree © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Work on this topic since 2005 * GCHQ initially interested in topic following use of a closed loop by the July 7, 2005 bombers * Analysis of anonymised meta-data for bulk UK-UK mobile call records indicated that this was a rare phenomenon and pointed to possible target discovery opportunities * Closed loop analysis of VOICESAIL showed promise but work was truncated * SANAR-08 presentation demonstrated that operational closed loops could in theory be discovered © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## The reality of target behaviour * Targets from different IPT's regularly purchase groups of cheap mobile phones and use them operationally for a short period (possibly as long as three months) before getting a new set * Two critical features: * Most of the phones start life at about the same time * Most of the phones are cheap handsets * Sometimes the targets make a mistake and make a call to a phone outside the closed loop © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## The process of looking for closed loops * Choose a time window (e.g. 10 days) * Clean up the data for that period * Componentize the graph * Extract the components that fit the closed loop definition © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## The effect of windowing * We need to window the data or else slip ups by the closed loop members will render the group invisible * Need to choose a window that is large enough to allow the giant component to form but not so large that we never see targets who periodically goof up. © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Some statistics about components * 1507405 edges and 1606330 nodes * 922135 nodes in the giant component (57%) * 222477 components, of which 218327 (98.1%) are trees * 4149 non-tree, non-giant components, involving 39927 nodes (2.5% of total) * 17 of these components had at least 70% of the nodes illuminating within a 3 week period. © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## A closed loop is born... ``` Untitled 1 File Edit Interface Selection Analysis Arrange Display Clustering Data Control Window Developer Help Mouse Mode Base Network * Nodes 5 * Links (Total) 325 * Links (Composite) 10 * Excluded Nodes 1 * Excluded Links 0 * Components 1 * Singulars 0 XXXXXX1851 XXXXXX8595 XXXXXX7496 XXXXXX3911 XXXXXX9539 ``` © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## When geolocation is not enough... * Targets love cheap handsets, bless 'em * Nokia occupy the largest segment of the cheap phone market. Nokia 1* phones are nasty. © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Nokia 1616 "Unashamedly aimed at the bottom end of the mobile phone spectrum... under the bonnet things remain distinctly unimpressive” © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Vodafone 252 “A very affordable handset that comes with basic voice call and message services" © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Samsung 1150 "This cut-price phone offers bare-bones functionality and lacks what many mobile users would deem to be essential features” © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH --- TOP SECRET STRAP1 ## Testing the cheap phone hypothesis * What type of handset did the July 7, 2005 London bombers use? * At least three of the four phones used on that day were a Nokia 1100 © Crown Copyright. All rights reserved. ICT RESEARCH