{ "title": "Tracking Targets Through Proxies & Anonymizers", "type": "REPORTED", "description": "This NSA presentation details methods for tracking and de-anonymizing internet users who employ privacy tools like Tor, proxies, and VPN services such as AnchorFree's Hotspot Shield. The document explains how the agency reverse-engineers anonymization tools, creates \"fingerprints\" to identify their traffic in surveillance systems, and correlates encrypted connections to reveal users' real IP addresses and locations—acknowledging this work \"makes for sad analysts\" when targets successfully obscure their identities.", "long_description": "This NSA presentation reveals the agency's systematic approach to defeating internet anonymization tools that individuals use to protect their privacy and avoid surveillance. The document, written in an unusually casual and irreverent style filled with pop culture references and humor, explains methodologies for tracking targets who use proxy servers, VPN services like AnchorFree's Hotspot Shield, and the Tor anonymity network. The presentation candidly acknowledges that tech-savvy targets \"generally don't like to have their communications tracked by government agencies\" and notes that the use of these privacy tools \"generally makes for sad analysts\" - followed by a sad face emoji. The author outlines a four-step process: identify new anonymization services, research and test them to understand how they work, create \"fingerprints\" in NSA surveillance systems to recognize their traffic patterns, and finally correlate that traffic with known target activity to reveal users' real identities and locations. The presentation admits upfront there is \"no silver bullet\" and that success requires \"both manual analysis and (generally) luck.\"\n\nThe technical details demonstrate sophisticated capabilities to unravel privacy protections. For AnchorFree's Hotspot Shield, the NSA discovered that while users connect to one IP address and appear to websites as coming from a different IP address, there exists a \"direct correlation between the two\" that can be mapped. This allows analysts to work backwards from a target's anonymized web activity to find their real IP address by examining tunnel connections. For Tor, which routes traffic through three randomly selected nodes wrapped in layers of SSL encryption, the NSA exploits the identifiable characteristics of Tor's SSL certificates to spot Tor circuits in intercepted traffic, and references a dataset called GOLDENFORTIN related to Tor exit node traffic. The presentation's methodology relies heavily on reverse-engineering these tools through open source research, packet analysis with Wireshark, and what the author cheekily describes as \"basically RTFM'ing about how stuff works and translating that to the SIGINT system.\"", "tags": [ "Tor", "proxies", "anonymizers", "AnchorFree", "deep packet inspection", "traffic fingerprinting", "network fingerprints", "traffic analysis", "traffic correlation", "anonymity", "de-anonymization", "privacy tools", "VPNs", "VPN analysis", "proxy detection", "IP address tracking", "user identification", "SIGINT analysis", "encryption breaking", "SSL", "certificate analysis", "network analysis", "IP correlation", "target tracking", "communications tracking", "network reconnaissance", "connection mapping", "SIGINT fingerprints", "signature detection", "traffic signatures", "mass surveillance", "identity revelation", "tech-savvy targets", "censorship circumvention", "analysts", "target analysis", "proxy traffic", "traffic classification", "Monty Python", "humor" ], "document": { "creator": "NSA", "date_created": "", "classification": [ "TOP SECRET", "SI" ], "dissemination": [ "REL 5EYES" ], "banner": "TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY", "genre": "slides", "programs": [ "XKEYSCORE", "GOLDENFORTIN" ], "countries": [], "people": [] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The Intercept", "date_published": "2016-06-28", "title": "He Was a Hacker for the NSA and He Was Willing to Talk. I Was Willing to Listen.", "link": "https://theintercept.com/2016/06/28/he-was-a-hacker-for-the-nsa-and-he-was-willing-to-talk-i-was-willing-to-listen/", "reporters": [ "Maass, Peter" ], "contributors": [ "McNeill, Sheelagh" ], "doc_url": "https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/2919708/Tracking-Targets-Through-Proxies-amp-Anonymizers.pdf" } ], "pdf_sha256": "86f9fde96a89b84519529d7eb18b20f94da4b70b2ac43547ef54fcc76fab2af2", "pages": 25 }