{ "title": "GCHQ Application for Renewal of Warrant GPW/1160", "type": "REPORTED", "description": "GCHQ’s 2008 application to renew warrant GPW/1160 seeks blanket cover under ISA section 5 to reverse engineer and modify commercial software—explicitly breaching copyright and licensing—to enable CNE, vulnerability research, and even police forensics. It catalogues concrete ops against web forums, routers, and antivirus, and asserts a novel legal theory blessed by the Intelligence Services Commissioner to immunize intellectual‑property interference.", "long_description": "The submission asks the Foreign Secretary to reissue an ISA s5 warrant authorizing “interference with computer software in breach of copyright and licensing agreements,” not tied to a single target but to an ongoing program of reverse engineering. GCHQ argues that RIPA or ISA s7 cover “enabling activities” when prep work is attached to a specific intercept or overseas CNE operation, but claims a legal gap for broad SRE done to maintain a “technical knowledge base” and develop future exploit paths, as well as CESG’s IA vulnerability research. It acknowledges there was “no precedent” for using s5 against intellectual property, but says the Intelligence Services Commissioner was consulted in 2005 and “was content” that s5 could remove liability—an extraordinary reinterpretation of a property interference power to green‑light copyright violations.\n\nOperationally, the warrant is justified with named targets and effects: SRE against vBulletin and Invision Power Board to recover credentials, find forum vulnerabilities, and “modify a forum” to attack users; CPanel and PostfixAdmin weaknesses enabling site modification and implant attempts; and “capability against Cisco routers” that placed a CNE presence on the Pakistan Internet Exchange, giving access to “almost any user of the internet inside Pakistan” and the ability to reroute selective traffic to passive collection systems. It flags Kaspersky and other personal security products as obstacles to CNE, requiring continued SRE to evade detection. CESG’s IA team is also covered to dissect malware and the monitoring tools FileMon and RegMon, and to evaluate government‑used products (e.g., Microsoft Mobile Data Manager). NTAC is explicitly cited as using the warrant to break Acer eDataSecurity and CrypticDisk—for police cases including child‑abuse investigations.\n\nThe risk assessment breezily declares the chance of discovery “negligible,” while the legal section asserts necessity and proportionality for national security and the UK’s economic well‑being. Read plainly, the application is a blueprint for bureaucratizing intrusion: a standing s5 warrant to bypass license terms and copyright whenever SRE is “necessary,” with spillover to domestic “police operations,” all under ministerial signature and commissioner acquiescence. It turns a property‑interference statute into a general shield for software hacking, normalizing a practice that would otherwise be unlawful.", "tags": [ "Computer Network Exploitation", "warrant", "ISA", "Intelligence Services Act", "property interference", "copyright infringement", "licensing breach", "reverse engineering", "SRE", "RIPA", "enabling activities", "CESG", "Information Assurance", "vulnerability research", "malware analysis", "FileMon", "RegMon", "Microsoft Mobile Data Manager", "NTAC", "police forensics", "Acer eDataSecurity", "CrypticDisk", "vBulletin", "Invision Power Board", "CPanel", "PostfixAdmin", "Cisco routers", "Pakistan Internet Exchange", "traffic redirection", "Kaspersky", "antivirus evasion", "interception", "ministerial warrant", "Foreign Secretary", "legal loophole", "web forums", "implant delivery", "passive collection", "router exploitation", "forums" ], "document": { "creator": "GCHQ", "date_created": "2008-06-13", "classification": [ "TOP SECRET", "STRAP 2" ], "dissemination": [ "UK EYES ONLY" ], "banner": "TOP SECRET STRAP2 UK EYES ONLY", "genre": "report", "programs": [], "countries": [ "Pakistan", "Russia" ], "people": [ "MacLeod, Sian", "Leslie, Mariot" ] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The Intercept", "date_published": "2015-06-22", "title": "Spies Hacked Computers Thanks to Sweeping Secret Warrants, Aggressively Stretching U.K. Law", "link": "https://theintercept.com/2015/06/22/gchq-reverse-engineering-warrants/", "reporters": [ "Fishman, Andrew", "Greenwald, Glenn" ], "contributors": [], "doc_source": "https://theintercept.com/document/2015/06/22/gchq-warrant-renewal/", "doc_url": "https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/2106826/gchq-application-for-renewal-of-warrant-gpw-1160.pdf" } ], "pdf_sha256": "fdfd9ac93d22f7e097d00e2b4874a12019fe517930a6456e1772a73a3d00fa9a", "pages": 5 }