# Synergising Network Analysis Tradecraft ## Network Tradecraft Advancement Team (NTAT) Collaborative Agile NTAT Empowering Pioneering DSD GCHQ GCSB NSA --- ## Overview * What is the NTAT? * 2011-2012 work and accomplishments ``` Dynamic Config Select values we want Turn ip into ip range Make decimal IP for filter Geo from ATLAS Dummy3 Remove 5 eyes & wrong coSelect values 2 Select values 3 Tag reserved ips Dummy2 TC Init Get HTTP for MMG > CC IPs (not browsers) Dummy1 Remove reserved IPs CC to lower Dummy4 Make an aggregation field by concatenating Wildcard url-keep first level folders only Select values Sort by ip 3 Group ip. port Sort rows 3 Output app server list Output PS requirements Count Existing port scan results Sort rows Add port Information (ATHENA) Rename fields to friendly names Sort by ip 2 Port scan required? NTAT ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Tradecraft? ### Tradecraft * "The development of methods, techniques, algorithms and processes in order to generate Intelligence, and developing the ability to apply this knowledge either manually or through automation. Tradecraft is developed from experience, research, intuition and by the reapplication and redefinition of existing techniques. Industrial- Scale Tradecraft involves data on a large scale." ### Network Tradecraft * Usable knowledge about how to acquire intelligence FROM the network TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The NTAT * Create repeatable, sustainable & shareable tradecraft to enable network analysis * Facilitate knowledge collaboration and interchange across the 5-Eyes SIGDEV community TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The Process Stage 1 = Fact Finding Stage 2 = Define Focus (based on Fact Finding) Stage 3 = Develop Tradecraft Stage 4 = Document Tradecraft Stage 5 = Test Documented Tradecraft and Refine TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Network Convergence Tradecraft * Technological convergence – where voice and data services interact with each other on a single device * Tradecraft to enable the targeting of handsets in telephony space and CNE exploitation in IP space * Improved algorithms for mobile gateway identification and implementation of these algorithms TOP SECRET//SI --- ## DSD Workshop November 2011 * 2 weeks * CSE, DSD, GCHQ * Virtually, via chat room, NSA & GCSB * Focus on data, techniques & analytic outcomes https://wiki.dsd/twiki/[REDACTED] [REDACTED] TOP SECRET//SI --- ## DSD Workshop Outcomes Technique developed to identify wide variety of potential converged data, unique for specific country or mobile network operator * potentially lead to convergence correlation dataset to help profile targets on-line activity Documentation of techniques to identify specific components of raw HTTP activity that alludes to the browsing, downloading and installation of smartphone applications * identified the presence of application servers for mobile network operators and geographical areas DSD implementation of mobile gateway identification analytic based on FRETTING YETI * three agencies now running the same analytic provides a richer dataset of mobile gateways CRAFTY SHACK trial * NTAT now using CRAFTY SHACK for tradecraft documentation TOP SECRET//SI --- ## XKS Microplugin: Samsung Protocol Samsung Protocol | State | ID | CSc | Device_Model | HTTP_User_Agent | Imei | Latest_Mcc | Mcc | Message_Id | Message_Type | Mnc | Network_Ty | Odc_Versio | Preloaded_apps | Version | Casenotation | | :---- | :--- | :--------- | :----------- | :-------------- | :--------- | :--------- | :-- | :--------- | :---------------------------- | :-- | :--------- | :--------- | :-------------------------------- | :------ | :-------------- | | 1 | 353 | KSA | GT-N7000 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-8 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 50 | 0 | 2.6.084 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapps@2 | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 2 | 566 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 3 | 648 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 4 | 649 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-1 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 5 | 1260 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 6 | 1261 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 7 | 1262 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-3 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 8 | 1274 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-4 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 9 | 1 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 10 | 67 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 11 | 433 | SKZ | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.148 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 12 | 463 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2350-0 | getPushNotificationMessage Re | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 13 | 1074 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2350-0 | getPushNotificationMessage Re | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 14 | 786 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | NFDJR00000M0171 | | 15 | 1110 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | NFDJR00000M0171 | | 16 | 664 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2308-0 | getKillList Request | 20 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 17 | 360 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 20 | 0 | | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 18 | 362 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 20 | 0 | | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 19 | 490 | XEU | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 50 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 20 | 572 | XEU | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 50 | 0 | | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 21 | 961 | THR | GT-B5512 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 40 | 0 | 2.6.122 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 22 | 964 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.194 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 23 | 965 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2302-2 | upgradeListEx Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.194 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 24 | 968 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2160-6 | purchaseDetailEx Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 25 | 1259 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-2 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 26 | 1344 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 412 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 27 | 1400 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2300-0 | countrySearchEx Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 28 | 54 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2200-1 | countrySearch Request | | 111 | | | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 29 | 417 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 5060-1 | termInformation Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 30 | 488 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | | | | | | | | | | TOP SECRET//SI --- ## CSE Workshop February 2012 * 2 weeks * CSE, DSD, GCHQ, GCSB, NSA – everyone wanted to experience a Canadian winter! * Build on the work started at DSD Winter Nirvana TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The Reality! --- ## CSE Workshop Outcomes Refinement of XKS fingerprints to identify mobile bearers, Samsung and Android Marketplace servers * 17 XKS fingerprints deployed Documentation of analytics in CRAFTY SHACK * These analytics are now being implemented across the 5 Eyes Proving the tradecraft actually works! * Scenario to test the tradecraft and analytics – Op IRRITANT HORN TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Op IRRITANT HORN AP Photo TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Op IRRITANT HORN ## Does the tradecraft work? * Another Arab Spring (only this time, different countries) * Goal: identify aggregation points for the mobile networks in the countries of interest using the tradecraft developed during the workshops * Did it work? YES -> the team was able to identify connections from the countries to application and vendor servers in non 5-Eyes countries * So what? We found some servers.... * Potential MiTM * Effects * Harvesting data at rest * Harvesting data in transit TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Finding mobile application & vendor update servers ``` TC Init Geolocation and Network Information (ATLAS): Date Range, IP Range Reverse DNS (DANAUS): IP Range Row Normaliser Bitterness Filter rows IP input Select valuesIP-IP Communication Summaries (HYPERION): Date Range, IP Range Tradecraft Navigator Output ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Finding mobile application & vendor update servers ``` TC Init Congo [REDACTED] Geolocation and france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com cuba store.cubava.cu cuba store.cubava.cu senegal srv_applis.sar.sn IP input Senegal [REDACTED] Select valuesIP-IP Communic Sudan [REDACTED] morocco boungeontelephone.com switzerland download-force.com bahamas supportapple.com cuba store.cubava.cu netherlands mobile.ero-advertising.com russia lady.marketgid.info ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ``` Crafty shack Change view [REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca Search this wiki Go Search Browse ▾ Search ▾ Create ▾ Help ▾ MediaWiki ▾ Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network Page Discussion History / Edit SECRET Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network 5 EYES | CSEC | DSD | GCHQ | GCSB | NSA | Factbox Metadata Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Alternatives: * Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network What does the tradecraft achieve? * This tradecraft will provide a list of servers that have been seen communicating with a mobile network. In what situations would this tradecraft be most useful? * To identify mobile application servers for a specific network * To identify any server that may be useful for collection purposes Describe any problems, caveats or things to watch out for * The list of servers returned depends on the the IP range and collection sources utilized. Success of this tradecraft may require additional research to identify other IP ranges or requesting other agencies to check their collection to identify different servers. Links that can help you to implement this tradecraft Created by: [REDACTED] Agency: NSA Email Address: [REDACTED] Difficulty: Acceptance state: Limited Input(s): Ontology Network block, Ontologylp address Output(s): Ontologylp address, Ontology ASN, Ontology Network block, Ontology Hostname, Ontology User Agent String, Ontology Geographic selector Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways ``` ``` Input(s): Ontology Network block, Ontologylp address Output(s): Ontologylp address, Ontology ASN, Ontology Network block, Ontology Hostname, Ontology User Agent String, Ontology Geographic selector Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Alternatives: * Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network 5 EYES Tradecraft Steps (document underlying analytic, do not include tools) The IP ranges utilized for the initial implementation of this tradecraft were the Inter PLMN Backbone IP ranges obtained from IR21 documents. For other methods of identifying mobile IP blocks, see the invoked tradecraft listed above. Step 1) Take IP ranges or individual addresses identified as being related to mobile network communications. Step 2) Obtain geolocation information and network ownership information for each IP address. This should include: Network Owner name, Carrier name, ASN, Continent, Country, Region, City, LatLong, and anyother related details that your system can obtain Step 3) Obtain Internet communication events related to the IP addresses. These events should minimally include: source information, To IP, From IP, TCP Direction, and HTTP User-Agent Step 4) Sort the results and dedup them. This step depends on your collection sources Step 5) Filter out server communications that have user-agents that aren't useful. Further analysis is needed to identify the non-useful user-agents (cheat sheet needed). Ex friendly-scanner Step 6) Check the TCP Direction field: * If Server to Client, grab the From IP information * If Client to Server, grab the To IP information * If Server to Server, grab both the To and From IP information * If Unknown, capture in an error log Step 7) Sort and dedup again based on Server IP information. TCP Direction info is no longer needed. Step 8) Obtain geolocation information and network ownership information for each Server IP. This is done for the servers that were not in the original IP Blocks. Step 9) Remove any servers that are not useful. This may include 5-Eyes servers. Step 10) Output * List of Servers * List of related User Agents * List of related hostnames Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Comments (2) | Show comments Average article quality based on 1 rating(s) Last updated 24/2/2012 by [REDACTED] Category: Tradecraft CRAFTY SHACK - "It's not tradecraft until it's documented! CSEC" [edit] ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Identifying servers communicating with an MNO ``` 100% Start Select Input CSV File CSV File Input TC Init Main Stream Add Sequence Remove Duplicates Normaliser SrcIP Dst Select Values Lookup Stream No Enrichment Found Link Buffer Mux Demux Enriched? Distribute Lookup DstIP Enrichment Bob TDI Online Events (PEITHO) ATLAS Geo and Network Info Dedup Is User Agent friendly scanner? ATLAS Geo and Network Info 2 Mux 2 Select values 2 Unique rows Is Server Client? Is Client Server? Initial IP and delete extras US = friendly-scanner Demux 2 Server within Range? Split Fields Sort rows Server Client Client-Server Is Server Server? Reformat 2 Alice Reformat 5-Eye places Remove 5-Eyes Iggy Sort UA Blocks Unique UA Blocks Select values 3 UserAgentData Combine Copy data Unknown_Direction Servers with Host Unique rows 22 Sort rows 2 Unique rows 2 convert create dash concatinate Sort rows 22 Servers convert 2 Reverse DNS (DANAUS): IP Range Google Earth ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` This tradecraft will accept a CSV file of known apps server hostnames. It will then perform reverse DNS queries to obtain the IP addresses of the apps servers. With the IP addresses, geolocation and network provider queries will be performed on all app server IP addresses. The IP addresses are then used to search for TDI events associated with those IP addresses. The result is a list of the apps servers with IP addresses, geolocation and provider details, as well as TDI events seen connecting to those apps servers. The TDI events are also queried to determine their geolocation and provider details. Start Define the input CSV file input TC Init Forward DNS (DANAUS) Hostname Filter to remove "too common" results in DNS e.g. google, bank, iTunes, etc. Dummy (do nothing) Filter rows Geolocation and Network Information (ATLAS): Date Range, IP Range Sort the rows to pass only unique TDIs Results Just apps server details Sort rows Apps Servers with Hostname, Geo and Network Details TDI Online Events (PEITHO): Date Range, IP Range Filter for CLIENT_TO_SERVER comms Sort rows 2 Filter rows 2 Geolocation and Network Information - Client to Server Comms Results All TDI events for each app server TDI Events for Apps Servers Dummy (do nothing) 2 Geo and Network of clients Results EVERYTHING! Each app server with IP address, geo and network details AND all TDI events for each app server with the geo and network details of the client side comms ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` Search - Search - Splunk 4.3.1 - Mozilla Firefox File Edit View History Bookmarks Tools Help http://magneto.sigint.cs[REDACTED] Most Visited NTAT Wikis XKEYSCORE CSE IntelliWiki IntelliWiki CEO GCHQ Wiki NSA Wiki DSD Wiki GCSB Wiki CRAFTY SHACK NAC Training Material SCORPIOFORE sam-mmap GlobalComms Home PLINKO MASTERSHAKE BLAZING SADDLES Splunk Disable Cookies CSS Forms Images Information Miscellaneous Outline Resize Tools View Source Options Approved Fingerprints | Search Search - Splunk 4.3.1 | splunk > Search Summary Search Status Dashboards & Views Searches & Reports Search source="E:\\Splunk\\NTAT[REDACTED] All time 236 matching events Save Create Hide Zoom out Linear scale 1 bar = 1 millisecond 1 51 41 000 PM Field discovery is: On Hide 236 events over all time Export Options 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 next > 10 per page 2 selected fields Edit - HTTP_User_Agent - source 38 interesting fields Application ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 ne[REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- ASN 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm = it[REDACTED] [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","[REDACTED] [REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] ,"bahrain","bh","al-manamah",[REDACTED] Carrier E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Case_Notation ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 [REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- City 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9800[REDACTED] Client_ASN Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry980[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", Client_Carrier <12> E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration Client_City ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 [REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- Client_Country <2> 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8520[REDACTED] Client_Digraph Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] Client_Country (categorical) Client_IP_Range Client_Owner Appears in 100% of results Charts Show only events with this field Top values by time ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- Country Select and show in results Top values overall realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8900[REDACTED] Digraph BlackBerry890[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Values # % host congo 102 43.22% hostname saudi arabia 65 27.542% ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- canada 58 24.576% realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9800[REDACTED] HTTP_Via cuba 4 1.695% -BlackBerry980[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", identifier peru 2 0.847% ▏ rofile/MIDP-2.0 index india 1 0.424% ▏ Client_Country 1 0.424% ▏ ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- IP indonesia 1 0.424% ▏ realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8520[REDACTED] IP_From bahrain 1 0.424% ▏ -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] IP_To togo 1 0.424% ▏ rofile/MIDP-2.0 linecount ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9700[REDACTED] -BlackBerry970[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", rofile/MIDP-2.0 x Find: access Next Previous Highlight all Match case Done ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` Field discovery is: On Hide 2 selected fields HTTP_User_Agent (18) source (1) 38 interesting fields Application (1) ASN (4) Carrier (4) Case_Notation (1) City (5) Client_ASN (1) Client_Carrier (1) Client_City (1) Client_Country (1) Client_Digraph (1) Client_IP_Range (1) Client_Owner (1) Country (4) Digraph (4) host (1) Hostname (8) HTTP_Via (1) Identifier (≥100) index (1) IP (B) IP_From (1) 18 results over all time Options Edit Formatting options ZTE-G-5213/WAP2.0 Nokia 5310Xpress Mus...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 WinWAP/3.2 Profile/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-SGH-L170/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-SGH-F250/....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-SGH-D600.... 1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-S3500/1.0...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-S3653...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-E2121B....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-GT-C3303...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-C3010....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-GT-B3210/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-C5212/CS...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-B5702/857...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Opera/9.80 (560: Sy...2.7.81 Version/11.00 Nokia6300/2.0 (06.01...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Nokia 6233/2.0 (04.5...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 LG-GU230/V10i Obig...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Client_Owner (categorical) Appears in 100% of results Show only events with this field Select and show in results Values warid congo Charts Top values by time Top values overall # % 102 100% Top 10 values 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 ``` * Results based on mobile application servers seen in CSE collection * We have a list of the most popular smartphones for Warid Congo customers and their IMSIs TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Success Stories * UCWeb mobile browser identification * Discovered by GCHQ analyst during DSD workshop * Chinese mobile web browser – leaks IMSI, MSISDN, IMEI and device characteristics TOP SECRET//SI --- ## UCWeb * Led to discovery of active comms channel from [REDACTED] (S//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) The CONVERGENCE team helped discover an active communication channel originating from [REDACTED] that is associated with the [REDACTED] as they are known within the [REDACTED] hierarchy area of responsibility is for covert activities in Europe, North America, and South America. The customer [REDACTED] leveraged a Convergence Discovery capability that enabled the discovery of a covert channel associated with smart phone browser activity in passive collection. The covert channel originates from users who use UCBrowser (mobile phone compact web browser). The covert channel leaks the IMSI, MSISDN, Device Characteristics, and IMEI back to server(s) in [REDACTED]. Initial investigation has determined that perhaps malware can be associated when the covert channel is established. [REDACTED] covert exfil activity identifies SIGINT opportunity where potentially none may have existed before. Target offices that have access to X-KEYSCORE can search within this type of traffic based on their IMSI or IMEI to determine target presence TOP SECRET//SI --- ## UCWeb – XKS Microplugin UCWeb Help Actions | Reports View | Map View | | State | ID | Datetime | Highlights | Datetime End | Browser Version | Email Address | Handset Model | IMEI | IMSI | Global Title | Platform | Active User/I | Casenotation | | ----- | --- | ------------------- | ---------- | ------------------- | --------------- | -------------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | ------------- | --------------- | | 1 | 1 | 2012-05-13 02:29:20 | | 2012-05-13 02:29:23 | 8.0.3.107 | [REDACTED]@123movies | nokiae90-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 9379900100 | java | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 2 | 3 | 2012-05-13 06:00:59 | | 2012-05-13 06:01:00 | 8.0.3.107 | [REDACTED]@123movies | nokiae90-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 9379900100 | java | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 3 | 4 | 2012-05-13 19:39:11 | | 2012-05-13 19:39:11 | 7.9.3.103 | | HTC A510e | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | android | | E9BDE00000M0000 | | 4 | 2 | 2012-05-14 12:29:53 | | 2012-05-14 12:29:53 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@djgol | Nokia E72-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | sis | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 5 | 5 | 2012-05-14 17:46:46 | | 2012-05-14 17:46:46 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | sis | | H5H125221450000 | | 6 | 6 | 2012-05-15 18:28:19 | | 2012-05-15 18:28:19 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 93781090013 | sis | | H5H125221450000 | | 7 | 7 | 2012-05-15 20:02:58 | | 2012-05-15 20:02:58 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 93781090013 | sis | | H5H12522145000 | TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Vision of Success * Shared convergence database with numerous different sources, methods & tradecraft feeding into it * Ultimately correlating telephony and Internet TDIs with some degree of confidence SUCCESS TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Synergising Network Analysis Tradecraft ### Network Tradecraft Advancement Team ## (NTAT) Collaborative Agile NTAT Empowering Pioneering DSD GCHQ GCSB NSA --- # Synergising Network Analysis Tradecraft ## Network Tradecraft Advancement Team (NTAT) Collaborative Agile NTAT Empowering Pioneering DSD GCHQ GCSB NSA --- ## Overview * What is the NTAT? * 2011-2012 work and accomplishments ``` Dynamic Config Select values we want Turn ip into ip range Make decimal IP for filter Geo from ATLAS Dummy3 Remove 5 eyes & wrong coSelect values 2 Select values 3 Tag reserved ips Dummy2 TC Init Get HTTP for MMG > CC IPs (not browsers) Dummy1 Remove reserved IPs CC to lower Dummy4 Make an aggregation field by concatenating Wildcard url-keep first level folders only Select values Sort by ip 3 Group ip. port Sort rows 3 Output app server list Output PS requirements Count Existing port scan results Sort rows Add port Information (ATHENA) Rename fields to friendly names Sort by ip 2 Port scan required? NTAT ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Tradecraft? ### Tradecraft * "The development of methods, techniques, algorithms and processes in order to generate Intelligence, and developing the ability to apply this knowledge either manually or through automation. Tradecraft is developed from experience, research, intuition and by the reapplication and redefinition of existing techniques. Industrial- Scale Tradecraft involves data on a large scale." ### Network Tradecraft * Usable knowledge about how to acquire intelligence FROM the network TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The NTAT * Create repeatable, sustainable & shareable tradecraft to enable network analysis * Facilitate knowledge collaboration and interchange across the 5-Eyes SIGDEV community TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The Process Stage 1 = Fact Finding Stage 2 = Define Focus (based on Fact Finding) Stage 3 = Develop Tradecraft Stage 4 = Document Tradecraft Stage 5 = Test Documented Tradecraft and Refine TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Network Convergence Tradecraft * Technological convergence – where voice and data services interact with each other on a single device * Tradecraft to enable the targeting of handsets in telephony space and CNE exploitation in IP space * Improved algorithms for mobile gateway identification and implementation of these algorithms TOP SECRET//SI --- ## DSD Workshop November 2011 * 2 weeks * CSE, DSD, GCHQ * Virtually, via chat room, NSA & GCSB * Focus on data, techniques & analytic outcomes https://wiki.dsd/twiki/[REDACTED] [REDACTED] TOP SECRET//SI --- ## DSD Workshop Outcomes Technique developed to identify wide variety of potential converged data, unique for specific country or mobile network operator * potentially lead to convergence correlation dataset to help profile targets on-line activity Documentation of techniques to identify specific components of raw HTTP activity that alludes to the browsing, downloading and installation of smartphone applications * identified the presence of application servers for mobile network operators and geographical areas DSD implementation of mobile gateway identification analytic based on FRETTING YETI * three agencies now running the same analytic provides a richer dataset of mobile gateways CRAFTY SHACK trial * NTAT now using CRAFTY SHACK for tradecraft documentation TOP SECRET//SI --- ## XKS Microplugin: Samsung Protocol Samsung Protocol | State | ID | CSc | Device_Model | HTTP_User_Agent | Imei | Latest_Mcc | Mcc | Message_Id | Message_Type | Mnc | Network_Ty | Odc_Versio | Preloaded_apps | Version | Casenotation | | :---- | :--- | :--------- | :----------- | :-------------- | :--------- | :--------- | :-- | :--------- | :---------------------------- | :-- | :--------- | :--------- | :-------------------------------- | :------ | :-------------- | | 1 | 353 | KSA | GT-N7000 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-8 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 50 | 0 | 2.6.084 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapps@2 | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 2 | 566 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 3 | 648 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 4 | 649 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-1 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 5 | 1260 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 6 | 1261 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 7 | 1262 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-3 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 8 | 1274 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-4 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 9 | 1 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 10 | 67 | AUT | GT-P7500 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 250 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 01 | 0 | 3.0.021 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 11 | 433 | SKZ | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.148 | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 12 | 463 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2350-0 | getPushNotificationMessage Re | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 13 | 1074 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2350-0 | getPushNotificationMessage Re | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 14 | 786 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | NFDJR00000M0171 | | 15 | 1110 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | NFDJR00000M0171 | | 16 | 664 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2308-0 | getKillList Request | 20 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 17 | 360 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 20 | 0 | | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 18 | 362 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 20 | 0 | | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 19 | 490 | XEU | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 50 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 20 | 572 | XEU | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2301-0 | getUpgradeNKillCount Request | 50 | 0 | | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 21 | 961 | THR | GT-B5512 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2309-0 | getDownloadList Request | 40 | 0 | 2.6.122 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 22 | 964 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-5 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.194 | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 23 | 965 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2302-2 | upgradeListEx Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.194 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 24 | 968 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2160-6 | purchaseDetailEx Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | cn.wps.m | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 25 | 1259 | XSG | GT-I9100 | | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2306-2 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | | com.sec.android.app.samsungapp | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 26 | 1344 | XSG | GT-I9100 | SAMSUNG-Android | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 412 | 2306-0 | checkAppUpgrade Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | | 1.0a | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 27 | 1400 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2300-0 | countrySearchEx Request | 20 | 0 | | | 3.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 28 | 54 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 2200-1 | countrySearch Request | | 111 | | | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 29 | 417 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | 412 | 5060-1 | termInformation Request | 20 | 0 | 2.6.048 | | 1.0 | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 30 | 488 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | | | | | | | | | | TOP SECRET//SI --- ## CSE Workshop February 2012 * 2 weeks * CSE, DSD, GCHQ, GCSB, NSA – everyone wanted to experience a Canadian winter! * Build on the work started at DSD Winter Nirvana TOP SECRET//SI --- ## The Reality! --- ## CSE Workshop Outcomes Refinement of XKS fingerprints to identify mobile bearers, Samsung and Android Marketplace servers * 17 XKS fingerprints deployed Documentation of analytics in CRAFTY SHACK * These analytics are now being implemented across the 5 Eyes Proving the tradecraft actually works! * Scenario to test the tradecraft and analytics – Op IRRITANT HORN TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Op IRRITANT HORN AP Photo TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Op IRRITANT HORN ## Does the tradecraft work? * Another Arab Spring (only this time, different countries) * Goal: identify aggregation points for the mobile networks in the countries of interest using the tradecraft developed during the workshops * Did it work? YES -> the team was able to identify connections from the countries to application and vendor servers in non 5-Eyes countries * So what? We found some servers.... * Potential MiTM * Effects * Harvesting data at rest * Harvesting data in transit TOP SECRET//SI MiTM – exploit the application server and use it as a MiTM platform for handset exploitation Effects – exploitation of the application servers could make it possible to provide selective misinformation to the targets handsets Harvesting data at rest – exploitation of the application servers could provide access to wealth of information at rest. The amount and usefulness of this information depends on the application in question Harvesting data in transit – mobile applications servers often send and receive data that SIGINT agencies find useful (e.g. the Samsung protocol sending client and handsets details to a server in Germany) --- ## Finding mobile application & vendor update servers ``` TC Init Geolocation and Network Information (ATLAS): Date Range, IP Range Reverse DNS (DANAUS): IP Range Row Normaliser Bitterness Filter rows IP input Select valuesIP-IP Communication Summaries (HYPERION): Date Range, IP Range Tradecraft Navigator Output ``` The results above are from a tradecraft to find servers of applications and vendor updaters servers from given countries, The rationale behind this is to identify servers that target within those countries might visit which could be exploited by CNE to push a phone implant capability. The tradecraft relies upon 5 tuple data seen from the mobile gateways from target countries and to servers which have matching 'key words' in the hostname. The results above could then be scoped for CNE to see if they would be valid boxes to use an access platform. TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Finding mobile application & vendor update servers ``` TC Init Congo [REDACTED] Geolocation and france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com france android-market.l.google.com cuba store.cubava.cu cuba store.cubava.cu senegal srv_applis.sar.sn IP input Senegal [REDACTED] Select valuesIP-IP Communic Sudan [REDACTED] morocco boungeontelephone.com switzerland download-force.com bahamas supportapple.com cuba store.cubava.cu netherlands mobile.ero-advertising.com russia lady.marketgid.info ``` The results above are from a tradecraft to find servers of applications and vendor updaters servers from given countries, The rationale behind this is to identify servers that target within those countries might visit which could be exploited by CNE to push a phone implant capability. The tradecraft relies upon 5 tuple data seen from the mobile gateways from target countries and to servers which have matching 'key words' in the hostname. The results above could then be scoped for CNE to see if they would be valid boxes to use an access platform. TOP SECRET//SI --- ``` Crafty shack Change view [REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca Search this wiki Go Search Browse ▾ Search ▾ Create ▾ Help ▾ MediaWiki ▾ Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network Page Discussion History / Edit SECRET Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network 5 EYES | CSEC | DSD | GCHQ | GCSB | NSA | Factbox Metadata Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Alternatives: * Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network What does the tradecraft achieve? * This tradecraft will provide a list of servers that have been seen communicating with a mobile network. In what situations would this tradecraft be most useful? * To identify mobile application servers for a specific network * To identify any server that may be useful for collection purposes Describe any problems, caveats or things to watch out for * The list of servers returned depends on the the IP range and collection sources utilized. Success of this tradecraft may require additional research to identify other IP ranges or requesting other agencies to check their collection to identify different servers. Links that can help you to implement this tradecraft Created by: [REDACTED] Agency: NSA Email Address: [REDACTED] Difficulty: Acceptance state: Limited Input(s): Ontology Network block, Ontologylp address Output(s): Ontologylp address, Ontology ASN, Ontology Network block, Ontology Hostname, Ontology User Agent String, Ontology Geographic selector Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways ``` ``` Input(s): Ontology Network block, Ontologylp address Output(s): Ontologylp address, Ontology ASN, Ontology Network block, Ontology Hostname, Ontology User Agent String, Ontology Geographic selector Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Alternatives: * Identify Servers communicating with a Mobile network 5 EYES Tradecraft Steps (document underlying analytic, do not include tools) The IP ranges utilized for the initial implementation of this tradecraft were the Inter PLMN Backbone IP ranges obtained from IR21 documents. For other methods of identifying mobile IP blocks, see the invoked tradecraft listed above. Step 1) Take IP ranges or individual addresses identified as being related to mobile network communications. Step 2) Obtain geolocation information and network ownership information for each IP address. This should include: Network Owner name, Carrier name, ASN, Continent, Country, Region, City, LatLong, and anyother related details that your system can obtain Step 3) Obtain Internet communication events related to the IP addresses. These events should minimally include: source information, To IP, From IP, TCP Direction, and HTTP User-Agent Step 4) Sort the results and dedup them. This step depends on your collection sources Step 5) Filter out server communications that have user-agents that aren't useful. Further analysis is needed to identify the non-useful user-agents (cheat sheet needed). Ex friendly-scanner Step 6) Check the TCP Direction field: * If Server to Client, grab the From IP information * If Client to Server, grab the To IP information * If Server to Server, grab both the To and From IP information * If Unknown, capture in an error log Step 7) Sort and dedup again based on Server IP information. TCP Direction info is no longer needed. Step 8) Obtain geolocation information and network ownership information for each Server IP. This is done for the servers that were not in the original IP Blocks. Step 9) Remove any servers that are not useful. This may include 5-Eyes servers. Step 10) Output * List of Servers * List of related User Agents * List of related hostnames Invokes Tradecraft: * Find public IP space used by Mobile Devices and Related Servers on the Internet * Finding Mobile Internet Gateways Comments (2) | Show comments Average article quality based on 1 rating(s) Last updated 24/2/2012 by [REDACTED] Category: Tradecraft CRAFTY SHACK - "It's not tradecraft until it's documented! CSEC" [edit] ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Identifying servers communicating with an MNO ``` 100% Start Select Input CSV File CSV File Input TC Init Main Stream Add Sequence Remove Duplicates Normaliser SrcIP Dst Select Values Lookup Stream No Enrichment Found Link Buffer Mux Demux Enriched? Distribute Lookup DstIP Enrichment Bob TDI Online Events (PEITHO) ATLAS Geo and Network Info Dedup Is User Agent friendly scanner? ATLAS Geo and Network Info 2 Mux 2 Select values 2 Unique rows Is Server Client? Is Client Server? Initial IP and delete extras US = friendly-scanner Demux 2 Server within Range? Split Fields Sort rows Server Client Client-Server Is Server Server? Reformat 2 Alice Reformat 5-Eye places Remove 5-Eyes Iggy Sort UA Blocks Unique UA Blocks Select values 3 UserAgentData Combine Copy data Unknown_Direction Servers with Host Unique rows 22 Sort rows 2 Unique rows 2 convert create dash concatinate Sort rows 22 Servers convert 2 Reverse DNS (DANAUS): IP Range Google Earth ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` This tradecraft will accept a CSV file of known apps server hostnames. It will then perform reverse DNS queries to obtain the IP addresses of the apps servers. With the IP addresses, geolocation and network provider queries will be performed on all app server IP addresses. The IP addresses are then used to search for TDI events associated with those IP addresses. The result is a list of the apps servers with IP addresses, geolocation and provider details, as well as TDI events seen connecting to those apps servers. The TDI events are also queried to determine their geolocation and provider details. Start Define the input CSV file input TC Init Forward DNS (DANAUS) Hostname Filter to remove "too common" results in DNS e.g. google, bank, iTunes, etc. Dummy (do nothing) Filter rows Geolocation and Network Information (ATLAS): Date Range, IP Range Sort the rows to pass only unique TDIs Results Just apps server details Sort rows Apps Servers with Hostname, Geo and Network Details TDI Online Events (PEITHO): Date Range, IP Range Filter for CLIENT_TO_SERVER comms Sort rows 2 Filter rows 2 Geolocation and Network Information - Client to Server Comms Results All TDI events for each app server TDI Events for Apps Servers Dummy (do nothing) 2 Geo and Network of clients Results EVERYTHING! Each app server with IP address, geo and network details AND all TDI events for each app server with the geo and network details of the client side comms ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` Search - Search - Splunk 4.3.1 - Mozilla Firefox File Edit View History Bookmarks Tools Help http://magneto.sigint.cs[REDACTED] Most Visited NTAT Wikis XKEYSCORE CSE IntelliWiki IntelliWiki CEO GCHQ Wiki NSA Wiki DSD Wiki GCSB Wiki CRAFTY SHACK NAC Training Material SCORPIOFORE sam-mmap GlobalComms Home PLINKO MASTERSHAKE BLAZING SADDLES Splunk Disable Cookies CSS Forms Images Information Miscellaneous Outline Resize Tools View Source Options Approved Fingerprints | Search Search - Splunk 4.3.1 | splunk > Search Summary Search Status Dashboards & Views Searches & Reports Search source="E:\\Splunk\\NTAT[REDACTED] All time 236 matching events Save Create Hide Zoom out Linear scale 1 bar = 1 millisecond 1 51 41 000 PM Field discovery is: On Hide 236 events over all time Export Options 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 next > 10 per page 2 selected fields Edit - HTTP_User_Agent - source 38 interesting fields Application ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 ne[REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- ASN 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm = it[REDACTED] [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","[REDACTED] [REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] ,"bahrain","bh","al-manamah",[REDACTED] Carrier E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Case_Notation ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 [REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- City 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9800[REDACTED] Client_ASN Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry980[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", Client_Carrier <12> E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration Client_City ▼ 9:11 "pws.ipoynt.com","EONBLUE","A","pws.ipoynt.com" [REDACTED] q9 [REDACTED] [REDACTED] "canada","ca","calgary","CAC- Client_Country <2> 1 51 41 000 PM 2024","MA30099",[REDACTED] ,"IMSI","webmai[REDACTED] realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8520[REDACTED] Client_Digraph Configuration/CLDC-1.1 VendorID/600","",[REDACTED] [REDACTED] -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", E:\Splunk\NTA[REDACTED] Client_Country (categorical) Client_IP_Range Client_Owner Appears in 100% of results Charts Show only events with this field Top values by time ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- Country Select and show in results Top values overall realm [REDACTED] ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8900[REDACTED] Digraph BlackBerry890[REDACTED] rofile/MIDP-2.0 Values # % host congo 102 43.22% hostname saudi arabia 65 27.542% ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- canada 58 24.576% realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9800[REDACTED] HTTP_Via cuba 4 1.695% -BlackBerry980[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", identifier peru 2 0.847% ▏ rofile/MIDP-2.0 index india 1 0.424% ▏ Client_Country 1 0.424% ▏ ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- IP indonesia 1 0.424% ▏ realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry8520[REDACTED] IP_From bahrain 1 0.424% ▏ -BlackBerry852[REDACTED] IP_To togo 1 0.424% ▏ rofile/MIDP-2.0 linecount ,"canada","ca","calgary","CAC- realm ,"CLIENT_TO_SERVER","","","BlackBerry9700[REDACTED] -BlackBerry970[REDACTED] etisalat etisalat company mobily","35819","saudi arabia","sa","ar_riya", rofile/MIDP-2.0 x Find: access Next Previous Highlight all Match case Done ``` TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Profiling mobile application servers ``` Field discovery is: On Hide 2 selected fields HTTP_User_Agent (18) source (1) 38 interesting fields Application (1) ASN (4) Carrier (4) Case_Notation (1) City (5) Client_ASN (1) Client_Carrier (1) Client_City (1) Client_Country (1) Client_Digraph (1) Client_IP_Range (1) Client_Owner (1) Country (4) Digraph (4) host (1) Hostname (8) HTTP_Via (1) Identifier (≥100) index (1) IP (B) IP_From (1) 18 results over all time Options Edit Formatting options ZTE-G-5213/WAP2.0 Nokia 5310Xpress Mus...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 WinWAP/3.2 Profile/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-SGH-L170/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-SGH-F250/....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-SGH-D600.... 1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-S3500/1.0...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-S3653...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-E2121B....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-GT-C3303...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-GT-C3010....1.101 (GUI) MMP/2.0 SAMSUNG-GT-B3210/...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-C5212/CS...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 SAMSUNG-B5702/857...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Opera/9.80 (560: Sy...2.7.81 Version/11.00 Nokia6300/2.0 (06.01...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Nokia 6233/2.0 (04.5...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 LG-GU230/V10i Obig...nfiguration/CLDC-1.1 Client_Owner (categorical) Appears in 100% of results Show only events with this field Select and show in results Values warid congo Charts Top values by time Top values overall # % 102 100% Top 10 values 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 62907100[REDACTED] 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 ``` * Results based on mobile application servers seen in CSE collection * We have a list of the most popular smartphones for Warid Congo customers and their IMSIs TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Success Stories * UCWeb mobile browser identification * Discovered by GCHQ analyst during DSD workshop * Chinese mobile web browser – leaks IMSI, MSISDN, IMEI and device characteristics TOP SECRET//SI --- ## UCWeb * Led to discovery of active comms channel from [REDACTED] (S//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) The CONVERGENCE team helped discover an active communication channel originating from [REDACTED] that is associated with the [REDACTED] as they are known within the [REDACTED] hierarchy area of responsibility is for covert activities in Europe, North America, and South America. The customer [REDACTED] leveraged a Convergence Discovery capability that enabled the discovery of a covert channel associated with smart phone browser activity in passive collection. The covert channel originates from users who use UCBrowser (mobile phone compact web browser). The covert channel leaks the IMSI, MSISDN, Device Characteristics, and IMEI back to server(s) in [REDACTED]. Initial investigation has determined that perhaps malware can be associated when the covert channel is established. [REDACTED] covert exfil activity identifies SIGINT opportunity where potentially none may have existed before. Target offices that have access to X-KEYSCORE can search within this type of traffic based on their IMSI or IMEI to determine target presence TOP SECRET//SI --- ## UCWeb – XKS Microplugin UCWeb Help Actions | Reports View | Map View | | State | ID | Datetime | Highlights | Datetime End | Browser Version | Email Address | Handset Model | IMEI | IMSI | Global Title | Platform | Active User/I | Casenotation | | ----- | --- | ------------------- | ---------- | ------------------- | --------------- | -------------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | ------------- | --------------- | | 1 | 1 | 2012-05-13 02:29:20 | | 2012-05-13 02:29:23 | 8.0.3.107 | [REDACTED]@123movies | nokiae90-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 9379900100 | java | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 2 | 3 | 2012-05-13 06:00:59 | | 2012-05-13 06:01:00 | 8.0.3.107 | [REDACTED]@123movies | nokiae90-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 9379900100 | java | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 3 | 4 | 2012-05-13 19:39:11 | | 2012-05-13 19:39:11 | 7.9.3.103 | | HTC A510e | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | android | | E9BDE00000M0000 | | 4 | 2 | 2012-05-14 12:29:53 | | 2012-05-14 12:29:53 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@djgol | Nokia E72-1 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | sis | | E9DHL00000M0000 | | 5 | 5 | 2012-05-14 17:46:46 | | 2012-05-14 17:46:46 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | | sis | | H5H125221450000 | | 6 | 6 | 2012-05-15 18:28:19 | | 2012-05-15 18:28:19 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 93781090013 | sis | | H5H125221450000 | | 7 | 7 | 2012-05-15 20:02:58 | | 2012-05-15 20:02:58 | 8.0.4.121 | [REDACTED]@mobimasti | NokiaX6-00 | [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] | 93781090013 | sis | | H5H12522145000 | TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Vision of Success * Shared convergence database with numerous different sources, methods & tradecraft feeding into it * Ultimately correlating telephony and Internet TDIs with some degree of confidence SUCCESS TOP SECRET//SI --- ## Synergising Network Analysis Tradecraft ### Network Tradecraft Advancement Team ## (NTAT) Collaborative Agile NTAT Empowering Pioneering DSD GCHQ GCSB NSA