{ "title": "INTOLERANT – Who Else Is Targeting Your Target? Collecting Data Stolen by Hackers – SIDtoday", "type": "SIDTODAY", "description": "A TOP SECRET SIDToday article from Menwith Hill Station describing how NSA and CSEC discovered and began exploiting INTOLERANT — a sophisticated email-stealing hacking operation targeting Indian diplomats, Central Asian diplomats, Chinese human rights defenders, Tibetan pro-democracy activists, Uighur activists and European officials — by intercepting the stolen emails as they transited satellite links, a technique internally called \"fourth party collection\" or \"outsourcing SIGINT.\"", "long_description": "This is a TOP SECRET//SI//REL SIDToday article originally published in Menwith Hill Station's Horizon newsletter in March 2010 and reprinted on SIDToday on June 2010. The article describes INTOLERANT, an email-stealing intrusion set discovered jointly by CSEC and Menwith Hill Station, and the practice of \"fourth party collection\" — intercepting data as it transits the internet from a hacking victim's computer to the attacker's infrastructure.\n\nINTOLERANT is described as a sophisticated operation in which unknown hackers targeted email accounts across seven victim categories: Indian diplomatic and Indian Navy (Category A), Central Asian diplomatic (B), Chinese human rights defenders (C), Tibetan pro-democracy personalities (D), Uighur activists (E), the European Special Representative to Afghanistan and Indian photo-journalism (F), and the Tibetan Government in Exile (G). The victim set is explicitly described as \"target-rich\" for the Intelligence Community — nearly half of observed traffic contained category hits against existing NSA targets. New victims' entire inboxes were exfiltrated going back months or years, followed by ongoing collection of new emails, with hundreds of emails observed on an average day.\n\nThe technical sophistication of INTOLERANT was considerable. The hackers' programmes split each stolen email into pieces, obfuscated each piece, assigned different spoofed source IP addresses and sent each to a different destination IP address routed across separate channels (PIDs — Packet Identifiers) of a satellite signal. The channels used carried large amounts of legitimate traffic, allowing the stolen data to hide as background noise. Collaboration between CSEC, MHS, GCHQ and NSAW was required to reassemble and transform the fragmented, obfuscated INTOLERANT data into readable SMTP email. The fact that data transited satellite links made it collectible at Menwith Hill Station, NSA's primary FORNSAT facility in the UK.\n\nAttribution was described as difficult. The level of sophistication and victim set pointed toward a likely state sponsor, but which state could not be determined. The satellite beam footprint was too large to narrow the attribution — the culprit needed to be within the beam's coverage to receive the stolen data, but the footprint covered a vast geographic area. The victim categories — Indian military and diplomats, Central Asian diplomats, Tibetan and Uighur activists, Chinese human rights defenders — are consistent with Chinese state-sponsored cyber espionage, though the article does not name China.\n\nThe article introduces the NSA terminology for this collection method: 4PXFIL stands for \"fourth party exfil\" — collecting intelligence that a third party (the hacker) has already stolen from a second party (the victim), making the NSA effectively the fourth party in the chain. The case notation format E9BDJ4PXFILtargetNumber was used to flag INTOLERANT-derived emails in SIGINT databases, so analysts reviewing their targets' intercepted communications could recognise when an email was available because someone else had hacked the target rather than through direct NSA collection. The article notes OPSEC concerns where US and UK authorities had contact with individuals in the victim set — particularly Indian diplomats and the European Special Representative — and states that NTOC was being informed.", "tags": [ "MHS", "Menwith Hill", "CSEC", "GCHQ", "NSAW", "fourth party", "4PXFIL", "outsourcing SIGINT", "cyber exploitation", "email theft", "state sponsored hacking", "Indian Navy", "diplomats", "Indian diplomats", "Central Asian diplomats", "Chinese human rights", "Tibet", "Tibetan Government in Exile", "Uighur", "European Special Representative", "FORNSAT", "satellite interception", "PID", "packet identifier", "SMTP", "obfuscation", "spoofed IP", "attribution", "NTOC", "OPSEC", "Horizon newsletter" ], "document": { "creator": "NSA", "date_created": "2010-05-06", "classification": [ "TOP SECRET", "SI" ], "dissemination": [ "REL" ], "banner": "DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL", "genre": "newsletter", "programs": [ "INTOLERANT" ], "countries": [ "India", "China", "Afghanistan", "Canada" ], "people": [] }, "publication": [ { "publisher": "The Intercept", "date_published": "2015-02-04", "title": "Western Spy Agencies Secretly Rely on Hackers for Intel and Expertise", "link": "https://theintercept.com/2015/02/04/demonize-prosecute-hackers-nsa-gchq-rely-intel-expertise/", "reporters": [ "Greenwald, Glenn" ], "contributors": [ "Marquis-Boire, Morgan" ], "doc_source": "https://theintercept.com/document/2015/02/04/intolerant-else-targeting-target-collecting-data-stolen-hackers/", "doc_url": "https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1588694/who-else-is-targeting-your-target-collecting.pdf" } ], "pdf_sha256": "9e1b1ff46b222483bd699a40aeb3d41211f3828f9fa233345970ca1174767e4b", "pages": 1 }