[ { "id": "prism-overview", "title": "PRISM/US-984XN briefing", "note": "Reconstruction from slides published separately by several outlets. The order after slide 12 is our best guess. The slides share one template and their dates fit an April 2013 briefing, but it is not proven that they all come from one deck: the three reporting tables highlight the S2H row, so they may come from a copy tailored for that unit. O Globo's slides are stills from its TV report and are blurred; of them, only 'Collection Only Possible Under FAA702 Authority' shows a slide number (9), and the other copies print none, so where O Globo's three slides sit in the order is also our guess.", "slides": [ {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "1-2"}, {"doc": "oglobo-prism", "pages": "4", "note": "O Globo TV still; the same title as the next slide, with a cable map."}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "3-5", "alt": [{"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "1-3"}]}, {"doc": "oglobo-prism", "pages": "1", "note": "O Globo TV still; numbered slide 9."}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "6-7"}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "version": "prism-entier", "pages": "8"}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "8"}, {"doc": "oglobo-prism", "pages": "3", "note": "O Globo TV still."}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "9-10"}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "version": "darkmirror", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "pages": "11"}]}, {"doc": "media_34016_Prasentation_uber_das_Spahprogramm_PRISM_und_die_Beteiligung_des_ECC", "pages": "1-3"}, {"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "4"}, {"doc": "oglobo-prism-a-week", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "nsa-prism-guardian-13-1101", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "5"}]}, {"doc": "prism-briefing-1", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "prism-briefing-2", "pages": "1"} ] }, { "id": "gchq-mobile-theme-2010", "title": "GCHQ Mobile Theme Briefing, 28 May 2010", "note": "The New York Times and The Guardian each published part of this GCHQ deck. The order of the two capability slides after the planning slide is our guess.", "slides": [ {"doc": "EFF_-_20140127-nyt-mobile_theme_briefing", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20140128-guard-leaky_phone_apps_0", "pages": "2"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20140127-nyt-mobile_theme_briefing", "pages": "2-4"}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20140128-guard-leaky_phone_apps_0", "pages": "3-4"} ] }, { "id": "sso-corporate-portfolio-2012", "title": "SSO Corporate Portfolio Overview, 20 March 2012", "note": "ProPublica and The New York Times published 16 slides with the speaker's notes; O Globo showed 27 slides in its TV report, 15 of them found nowhere else; The Intercept published three clean slides in 2018. The order follows the notes-page copy, then the Corporate Portfolio slide's program list for the OAKSTAR sites; O Globo's FAIRVIEW traffic views are in O Globo's own order.", "slides": [ {"doc": "20180320-theintercept__second_look_sso_20mar2012_wstormbrewmap", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "1"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "2-3"}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "4-5", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "1,5"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "6-7", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "4,3"}]}, {"doc": "20180320-theintercept__second_look_sso_20mar2012_wstormbrewmap", "pages": "2", "alt": [{"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "8"}, {"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "2"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "9"}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "10", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "17"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "11-12", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "16,15"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "13", "note": "The other copy, O Globo's, does not redact the Key Targets line: \"Russia and European Counterterrorism\".", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "14"}]}, {"doc": "sso-corpteambrief20mar2012-s2d", "pages": "14-16", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "13,11,12"}]}, {"doc": "20180320-theintercept__second_look_sso_20mar2012_wstormbrewmap", "pages": "3", "alt": [{"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "10"}]}, {"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "9,8,7,6", "note": "O Globo TV still."}, {"doc": "oglobo-sso", "pages": "18-27", "note": "O Globo TV still."} ] }, { "id": "xkeyscore-intro-2008", "title": "XKEYSCORE intro, 25 February 2008", "note": "The Guardian (2013) and The Intercept (2015) each published this NSA training deck, and each copy fills the other's gaps: The Guardian blacked out three slides that The Intercept shows (Document Tracking, XKEYSCORE and TRAFFICTHIEF, XKEYSCORE Success), and The Intercept left out two that The Guardian has (Discovery of new target web services, Entity Extraction). The order is The Guardian's 32 slides. O Globo's TV report also showed a satellite map around Delhi that matches no slide here; it is left out.", "slides": [ {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "1-21", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "1-21"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "22", "note": "Blacked out in The Guardian's copy.", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "22"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "23-24", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "23-24"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "25-26", "note": "Not in The Intercept's copy."}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "27-28", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "25-26"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "27-28", "note": "Blacked out in The Guardian's copy.", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "29-30"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "pages": "31-32", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20130731-guard-xkeyscore_training_slides", "version": "xks-intro", "pages": "29-30"}]} ] }, { "id": "boundlessinformant-screens-2013", "title": "BOUNDLESSINFORMANT screens, 10 Dec 2012 - 8 Jan 2013", "note": "Not one deck: separately published screens of the NSA's BOUNDLESSINFORMANT tool, each showing the same 30 days. Global views first, then programs and partners, then countries. The FAQ and the Dagbladet capabilities slides are documents, not screens, and are left out.", "slides": [ {"doc": "media_34004_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Ubersicht_global", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34007_Ubersicht_uber_den_Einsatz_des_Programms_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Weltkarte", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media-34008", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "boundlessinformant-sso", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "boundlessinformant-fairview", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131104-wapo-windstop", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "boundlessinformant-united-states", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34009_Zoom_in_ein_Dokument_zu_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_mit_Projektnamen", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34006_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Statistik_zu_Daten_von_Foreign_Partners", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34005_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Statistik_fur_die_sogenannten_3rd_Partys_zu_denen_auch_Deutschland_zahlt", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34003_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Statistik_fur_Grossbritannien", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "media_34002_BOUNDLESS_INFORMANT_Statistik_fur_Deutschland", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131021-monde-boundless_informant_france", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131028-mundo-spain_collections", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "boundlessinformant-italy", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "nsa-mivd-boundless", "pages": "1", "note": "That country's government said these were records its own service collected and shared, not NSA collection of its people."}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131119-dagbladet-norway_collection_0", "pages": "1", "note": "That country's government said these were records its own service collected and shared, not NSA collection of its people."}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131122-dagbladet-afghanistan_collection", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "boundlessinformant-poland", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "DENMARK-Last-30-Days-01092013", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "SWEDEN-Last-30-Days-01092013", "pages": "1"} ] }, { "id": "sso-corporate-partner-access", "title": "Special Source Operations: Corporate Partner Access", "note": "ProPublica and The New York Times published 19 slides; The Intercept's 7-slide copy adds BLARNEY Domestic Court Orders after slide 4. The Guardian and No Place to Hide carry single slides.", "slides": [ {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "1"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "2", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "2"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "3", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "3"}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "sso1", "pages": "1"}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "2"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "4", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "4"}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "4"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "5", "note": "Only in The Intercept's copy."}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "5-6", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "TSSINFCorporateOverview", "pages": "6-7"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "7", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "no-place-to-hide", "pages": "3"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "8-16"}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "17", "alt": [{"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "version": "sso2", "pages": "1"}]}, {"doc": "tssinfcorporateoverview", "pages": "18-19"} ] }, { "id": "sso-collection-optimization", "title": "SSO Collection Optimization", "note": "The Washington Post published two excerpts with the same title slide: address books (14 October 2013) and TUDDS, Google and new protocols (4 November 2013). Each keeps its own order; how the two fit together is not known. EFF calls the November set \"Midpoint\" slides, so the two may be separate presentations sharing a title. The address-book slide also appears in the Content Acquisition Optimization deck.", "slides": [ {"doc": "EFF_-_20131014-wapo-content_acquisition_optimization1", "pages": "1", "alt": [{"doc": "EFF_-_20131104-wapo-optimization_google", "pages": "1"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131014-wapo-content_acquisition_optimization1", "pages": "2", "alt": [{"doc": "ACLU_-_a-sso-content-optimization-detailed-redacted", "pages": "3"}]}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131014-wapo-content_acquisition_optimization1", "pages": "3-7"}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131104-wapo-optimization_google", "pages": "2-4"}, {"doc": "muscular-smiley-wapo-20131030", "pages": "1", "note": "Published with the MUSCULAR story on 30 October 2013. Same SSO seal, title bar, banners and title as the slide before; the deck repeats titles on consecutive slides. No source names the deck it came from."}, {"doc": "EFF_-_20131104-wapo-optimization_google", "pages": "5-6"} ] } ]