first commit
This commit is contained in:
commit
0d90363116
6510 changed files with 679146 additions and 0 deletions
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,919 @@
|
|||
U.S. FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE
|
||||
SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
UNITED STATES FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE SURVEILLANCE COURT2013 NOV 12 PM 3:41
|
||||
WASHINGTON, D.C.
|
||||
LEEANN FLYNN HALL
|
||||
CLERK OF COURT
|
||||
IN RE MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC.
|
||||
FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT RECORDS
|
||||
)
|
||||
)
|
||||
Docket No.: 13-09
|
||||
|
||||
MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC. FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT RECORDS
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene
|
||||
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94109
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
|
||||
Counsel for Movant ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
TABLE OF CONTENTS
|
||||
|
||||
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT.................................................................................................... 1
|
||||
|
||||
FACTUAL BACKGROUND....................................................................................................... 3
|
||||
|
||||
JURISDICTION.......................................................................................................................... 5
|
||||
|
||||
ARGUMENT................................................................................................................................ 6
|
||||
|
||||
I. MOVANT HAS STANDING UNDER ARTICLE III TO SEEK THE RELIEF
|
||||
REQUESTED .............................................................................................................. 6
|
||||
|
||||
II. THERE ARE NO KNOWN COMITY CONCERNS THAT SERVE AS A
|
||||
BAR TO THE CONSIDERATION OF THIS MOTION ........................................ 7
|
||||
|
||||
III. THE FIRST AMENDMENT COMPELS THE RELEASE OF THE COURT'S
|
||||
OPINIONS................................................................................................................... 8
|
||||
|
||||
A. There is a First Amendment Right of Access to Judicial Opinions.........................8
|
||||
1. Experience.......................................................................................................11
|
||||
2. Logic...............................................................................................................11
|
||||
|
||||
B. The First Amendment Permits the Withholding of Only Those Portions
|
||||
of the Opinion Found Necessary to Protect National Security.............................13
|
||||
|
||||
IV. ALTERNATIVELY, THE COURT SHOULD EXERCISE ITS DISCRETION
|
||||
TO RELEASE THE OPINIONS SOUGHT..............................................................15
|
||||
|
||||
CONCLUSION........................................................................................................................... 16
|
||||
|
||||
i
|
||||
|
||||
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
|
||||
Federal Cases
|
||||
|
||||
Applications of Nat'l Broad. Co., Inc. v. Presser,
|
||||
828 F.2d 340 (6th Cir. 1987) ................................................................................10
|
||||
|
||||
Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp. v. FTC,
|
||||
710 F.2d 1165 (6th Cir. 1983) ........................................................................8, 9, 13
|
||||
|
||||
Cal-Almond, Inc. v. U.S. Dep't of Agric.,
|
||||
960 F.2d 105 (9th Cir. 1992)................................................................................10
|
||||
|
||||
Clapper v. Amnesty Int'l USA,
|
||||
133 S. Ct. 1138 (2013)............................................................................................6
|
||||
|
||||
Del. Coal. for Open Gov't v. Strine,
|
||||
No. 1-11-cv-01015 (3d Cir. Oct. 23, 2013).....................................................10, 11
|
||||
|
||||
Detroit Free Press v. Ashcroft,
|
||||
303 F.3d 681 (6th Cir. 2004) ..........................................................................10, 12
|
||||
|
||||
El Vocero de P.R. v. Puerto Rico,
|
||||
508 U.S. 147 (1993) ..............................................................................................10
|
||||
|
||||
Fed. Election Comm'n v. Akins,
|
||||
524 U.S. 11 (1998) ..................................................................................................7
|
||||
|
||||
Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court,
|
||||
457 US 596 (1982) ..................................................................................................8
|
||||
|
||||
Grove Fresh Distributors, Inc. v. Everfresh Juice Co.,
|
||||
24 F.3d 893 (7th Cir. 1994) ..................................................................................14
|
||||
|
||||
Hicklin Engineering, LC v. Bartell,
|
||||
439 F. 3d 346 (7th Cir. 2006) ..............................................................................13
|
||||
|
||||
In re Application of the FBI for an Order Requiring the Production of Tangible Things
|
||||
From [Redacted], No. BR 13-109 (FISA Ct. Aug. 29, 2013)...............................passim
|
||||
|
||||
In Re Application of the FBI for an Order Requiring the Production of Tangible Things
|
||||
from [Redacted], No. BR 13-158 (FISA Ct. Oct. 11, 2013) ...................................2
|
||||
|
||||
In re Directives [Redacted] Pursuant to Section 105B of the Foreign Intelligence
|
||||
Surveillance Act, No. 08-01 (FISA Ct. Rev. Jan. 12, 2009)..................................16
|
||||
|
||||
ii
|
||||
|
||||
In re Dow Jones & Co., Inc.,
|
||||
842 F.2d 603 (2nd Cir. 1988) ................................................................................7
|
||||
|
||||
In re Motion for Release of Court Records,
|
||||
526 F. Supp. 2d 484 (FISA Ct. 2007)..........................................................6, 9, 13, 15
|
||||
|
||||
In re Oliver,
|
||||
333 U.S. 257 (1948) ..............................................................................................12
|
||||
|
||||
In re Orders of this Court Interpreting Section 215 of the Patriot Act at 16-17,
|
||||
No. Misc. 13-02 (FISA Ct. Sep. 13, 2013)..........................................................passim
|
||||
|
||||
Lowenschuss v. West Pub. Co.,
|
||||
542 F.2d 180 (3d Cir. 1976) ..............................................................................9, 10
|
||||
|
||||
Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife,
|
||||
504 U.S. 555 (1992) ................................................................................................6
|
||||
|
||||
N.Y. Civil Liberties Union v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.,
|
||||
684 F.3d 286 (2d Cir. 2012) ....................................................................................7
|
||||
|
||||
Nixon v. Warner Commc'ns Inc.,
|
||||
435 U.S. 589 (1978) ..........................................................................................5, 15
|
||||
|
||||
Press-Enter. Co. v. Superior Court,
|
||||
464 U.S. 501 (1984) ..............................................................................................14
|
||||
|
||||
Press-Enter. Co. v. Superior Court,
|
||||
478 U.S. 1 (1986) ................................................................................................passim
|
||||
|
||||
Raines v. Byrd,
|
||||
529 U.S. 811 (1997) ................................................................................................6
|
||||
|
||||
Redacted,
|
||||
2011 WL 10945618 (FISA Ct. Oct. 3, 2011)......................................................11
|
||||
|
||||
Redacted,
|
||||
2012 WL 9189263 (FISA Ct. Aug. 24, 2012)......................................................11
|
||||
|
||||
Richmond Newspapers Inc. v. Virginia,
|
||||
448 U.S. 555 (1980) ..........................................................................................8, 12
|
||||
|
||||
Smith v. Maryland,
|
||||
442 U.S. 735 (1979) ..........................................................................................3, 5
|
||||
|
||||
iii
|
||||
|
||||
United States v Rosen,
|
||||
487 F. Supp. 2d 703 (E.D. Va. 2007)..................................................................14
|
||||
|
||||
United States v. Jones,
|
||||
132 S. Ct. 945 (2012)................................................................................................2
|
||||
|
||||
United States v. Simone,
|
||||
14 F.3d 833 (3d Cir. 1994) ..................................................................................10
|
||||
|
||||
Federal Statutes
|
||||
|
||||
50 U.S.C. § 1861 ....................................................................................................passim
|
||||
|
||||
Federal Rules
|
||||
|
||||
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court's Rule of Procedure 62........................1, 15, 16
|
||||
|
||||
Constitutional Provisions
|
||||
|
||||
First Amendment....................................................................................................passim
|
||||
Fourth Amendment................................................................................................passim
|
||||
|
||||
Other Authorities
|
||||
|
||||
Charlie Savage, Extended Ruling by Secret Court Backs Collection of Phone Data,
|
||||
N.Y. Times, Sep. 17, 2013 ........................................................................................5
|
||||
|
||||
Jennifer Valentino DeVries & Siobhan Gorman, Secret Court's Redefinition of 'Relevant'
|
||||
Empowered Vast NSA Data-Gathering, Wall St. J. (July 8, 2013, 3:13 AM)............12
|
||||
|
||||
Jim Sensenbrenner, Op-Ed., How Obama Has Abused the Patriot Act, L.A. Times,
|
||||
Aug. 19, 2013 ............................................................................................................4
|
||||
|
||||
John Locke, Treatise of Civil Government §§ 124, 136-37 (1690)............................13
|
||||
|
||||
Julian Sanchez, Are Internet Backbone Pen Registers Constitutional?, Just Security
|
||||
(Sep. 23, 2013, 7:55 PM)..........................................................................................5
|
||||
|
||||
Office of the Dir. of Nat'l Intelligence, IC on the Record, DNI Clapper Declassifies
|
||||
Intelligence Community Documents Regarding Collection Under Section 501 of the
|
||||
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) (Sep. 10, 2013)................................11
|
||||
|
||||
Office of the Dir. of Nat'l Intelligence, IC on the Record, Release of Previously Classified
|
||||
August 29, 2013 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court Opinion (Sep. 17, 2013, 4:58
|
||||
PM)..........................................................................................................................14
|
||||
|
||||
iv
|
||||
|
||||
Orin Kerr, Hints and Questions About the Secret Fourth Amendment Rulings of the FISA
|
||||
Court, Volokh Conspiracy (July 7, 2013, 1:37 AM)................................................12
|
||||
|
||||
Orin Kerr, My (Mostly Critical) Thoughts on the August 2013 FISC Opinion on Section 215,
|
||||
The Volokh Conspiracy (Sep. 17, 2013, 7:39 PM)....................................................5
|
||||
|
||||
Statement by the President, Office of the Press Secretary (June 7, 2013) ................4
|
||||
|
||||
Status Report, Elec. Frontier Found. v. U.S. Dep't of Justice,
|
||||
No. 4:11-cv-05221 (N.D. Cal. Sep. 04, 2013), ECF No. 63....................................8
|
||||
|
||||
U.S. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court Public Filings (last visited October 8, 2013).........11
|
||||
|
||||
Zoë Carpenter, Congress Renews Efforts to Curb NSA Surveillance,
|
||||
The Nation (Sep. 24, 2013, 4:52 PM)........................................................................5
|
||||
|
||||
v
|
||||
|
||||
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
|
||||
|
||||
Pursuant to the First Amendment and to Rule 62 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance
|
||||
Court's Rules of Procedure ("FISC Rules"), ProPublica, Inc. (“ProPublica") respectfully moves
|
||||
for the publication of a certain Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court ("FISC") opinion or
|
||||
opinions that appear to underlie the government's collection of telephone metadata. The specific
|
||||
opinion or opinions sought are those referenced on, but redacted from, pages 8, 9, and 19-20 of
|
||||
In re Application of the FBI for an Order Requiring the Production of Tangible Things From
|
||||
[Redacted], No. BR 13-109 (FISA Ct. Aug. 29, 2013) (“BR 13-109").
|
||||
|
||||
The opinion or opinions sought are cited in BR 13-109 as stating "[s]o long as no
|
||||
individual has a reasonable expectation of privacy in meta[]data, the large number of persons
|
||||
whose communications will be subjected to the . . . surveillance is irrelevant to the issue of
|
||||
whether a Fourth Amendment search or seizure will occur." BR 13-109 at 8-9 (quoting
|
||||
[Redacted], at 63). The Court further cited to the opinion or opinions sought, stating, "This Court
|
||||
has previously examined the issue of relevance." Id. at 19-20. Lastly, movant seeks the opinion
|
||||
or opinions quoted on page 20 of BR 13-109 as follows:
|
||||
|
||||
* The "finding of relevance most crucially depended on the conclusion that bulk
|
||||
collection is necessary for NSA to employ tools that are likely to generate useful
|
||||
investigative leads to help identify and track terrorist operatives."
|
||||
* Bulk collections are "necessary to identify the much smaller number of
|
||||
[international terrorist] communications."
|
||||
* "[T]he entire mass of collected metadata is relevant to investigating [international
|
||||
terrorist groups] and affiliated persons."
|
||||
|
||||
1
|
||||
|
||||
These records should be unsealed because the public has a First Amendment right of
|
||||
access to them.
|
||||
|
||||
In the alternative, this Court, recognizing the considerable public interest in the opinions
|
||||
sought, should exercise its discretion to publish its own opinions. The opinions to which access
|
||||
is sought appear to set forth the FISC's ultimate legal authority supporting bulk collection of
|
||||
telephone call records pursuant to Section 215 of the USA PATRIOT Act. As this Court recently
|
||||
noted in the context of a request to unseal different FISC records, there is such a "considerable
|
||||
public interest" in the FISC opinions interpreting "the meaning, scope, and constitutionality of
|
||||
Section 215" because the publication of such opinions will “contribute to an informed debate...
|
||||
[and] assure citizens of the integrity of this Court's proceedings." In re Orders of this Court
|
||||
Interpreting Section 215 of the Patriot Act at 16-17, No. Misc. 13-02 (FISA Ct. Sep. 13, 2013)
|
||||
("Misc. 13-02"). Although numerous FISC opinions regarding Section 215 have now been made
|
||||
public, the FISC's ultimate authority for the bulk collection of records remains secret.¹ Like
|
||||
nesting dolls, the opinions that have been released thus far merely cite to redacted opinions, and
|
||||
when those opinions are released, they too cite to and rely on other redacted opinions. For the
|
||||
same reasons supporting the conclusion that the public interest would be served by the disclosure
|
||||
of opinions interpreting Section 215, the Court should provide the full legal rationale by
|
||||
publishing its opinions relied on in the now-public BR 13-109.
|
||||
|
||||
¹ The FISC's most recent published Section 215 order discusses bulk collection of metadata and
|
||||
the Fourth Amendment in the context of the Supreme Court's decision in United States v. Jones,
|
||||
132 S. Ct. 945 (2012). In Re Application of the FBI for an Order Requiring the Production of
|
||||
Tangible Things from [Redacted], No. BR 13-158 (FISA Ct. Oct. 11, 2013). However, the Court
|
||||
reaffirmed the analysis from BR 13-109, underscoring the importance of the still-secret opinions
|
||||
sought here. Id. at 4-5.
|
||||
|
||||
2
|
||||
|
||||
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
|
||||
|
||||
On September 17, 2013, the FISC released a partially redacted version of a previously
|
||||
classified August 29, 2013 memorandum opinion requiring a telephone service provider to
|
||||
produce bulk "telephony metadata" on an ongoing basis to the National Security Agency
|
||||
("NSA"), pursuant to Section 215. See BR 13-109 at 1-2. Relying on the Supreme Court's 1979
|
||||
opinion in Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735 (1979), for the proposition "that a person does not
|
||||
have a legitimate expectation of privacy in telephone numbers dialed," the Court held that bulk
|
||||
collection of telephony metadata under Section 215 does not violate the Fourth Amendment. Id.
|
||||
at 8-9. The Court noted the significant distinction that in Smith "the government was obtaining
|
||||
the telephone company's metadata of one person suspected of a crime... [but] [h]ere the
|
||||
government is requesting daily production of certain telephony metadata in bulk... without
|
||||
specifying the particular number of an individual." Id. at 8. However, the Court concluded that
|
||||
this was a distinction without a difference because "where one individual does not have a Fourth
|
||||
Amendment interest, grouping together a large number of similarly situated individuals cannot
|
||||
result in a Fourth Amendment interest springing into existence ex nihilo." Id. at 9. The Court's
|
||||
authority for this conclusion was a redacted citation to an earlier FISC opinion "analyz[ing] this
|
||||
distinction in a similar context." Id. at 8. Similarly, in its statutory analysis of whether bulk
|
||||
collection of telephony metadata meets Section 215's relevance standard, the Court again
|
||||
provided a redacted citation to an earlier FISC opinion. Id. at 19 ("This Court has previously
|
||||
examined the issue of relevance for bulk collections. See [redacted].") Relying on this redacted
|
||||
|
||||
3
|
||||
|
||||
opinion,² the Court concluded that the bulk collection fit within Section 215's statutory language.
|
||||
Id. at 20-21.
|
||||
|
||||
The release of this redacted BR 13-109 opinion interpreting Section 215 occurred against
|
||||
the backdrop of the FISC's public ruling four days earlier on a motion by the American Civil
|
||||
Liberties Union (“ACLU"), the American Civil Liberties Union of the Nation's Capital
|
||||
(“ACLU-NC”), and the Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic (“MFIAC”) (hereinafter
|
||||
collectively "the ACLU") requesting that the Court release FISC opinions interpreting
|
||||
Section 215. See Misc. 13-02. As an exercise of its discretion, the FISC held that any opinions
|
||||
not already at issue in the ACLU's ongoing FOIA litigation should be reviewed for
|
||||
declassification and published subject to the approval of the authoring judge. Id. at 16, 18.
|
||||
Although it did not reach the merits of the ACLU's asserted First Amendment right of access,
|
||||
the Court agreed that release of these opinions would serve the public interest and inform the
|
||||
ongoing debate. Id. at 16-17.
|
||||
|
||||
In addition to these public releases by the FISC, there has been a significant public debate
|
||||
regarding the legality of the telephone call records collection since the disclosure of the existence
|
||||
of the program in June 2013. In June, after The Guardian and the Washington Post disclosed a
|
||||
FISC order allowing bulk collection of telephony metadata under Section 215, public debate
|
||||
intensified. President Obama as well as other members of the executive and legislative branch
|
||||
spoke publicly about the program and "welcome[d] this debate." Statement by the President,
|
||||
Office of the Press Secretary (June 7, 2013), http://1.usa.gov/12xerjF; see also Jim
|
||||
Sensenbrenner, Op-Ed., How Obama Has Abused the Patriot Act, L.A. Times, Aug. 19, 2013,
|
||||
|
||||
² Because of the redactions, it is unclear whether the Court was citing to a single opinion or to
|
||||
two or more. See BR 13-109 at 20 (several redacted citations on the subject bulk collections and
|
||||
relevance).
|
||||
|
||||
4
|
||||
|
||||
http://www.latimes.com/opinion/commentary/la-oe-sensenbrenner-data-patriot-act-obama-
|
||||
20130819,0,1387481.story (criticizing executive branch's interpretation of Section 215); Zoë
|
||||
Carpenter, Congress Renews Efforts to Curb NSA Surveillance, The Nation (Sep. 24, 2013, 4:52
|
||||
PM),
|
||||
http://www.thenation.com/blog/176328/congress-renews-efforts-curb-nsa-surveillance
|
||||
(discussing congressional proposals to revise Section 215 to end bulk collection).
|
||||
|
||||
The FISC's release of the BR 13-109 opinion on September 17 has amplified public
|
||||
discussion of the Court's interpretation of the statute. See, e.g., Charlie Savage, Extended Ruling
|
||||
by Secret Court Backs Collection of Phone Data, N.Y. Times, Sep. 17, 2013,
|
||||
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/18/us/opinion-by-secret-court-calls-collection-of-phone-data-
|
||||
legal.html. Yet despite the FISC's release of this opinion, commentators have noted that the
|
||||
Court's legal analysis remains skeletal because of its reliance on earlier, still-secret opinions. See
|
||||
Julian Sanchez, Are Internet Backbone Pen Registers Constitutional?, Just Security (Sep. 23,
|
||||
2013, 7:55 PM), http://justsecurity.org/2013/09/23/internet-backbone-pen-registers-constitutional
|
||||
(referencing citation of secret Fourth Amendment opinions and these opinions' possible
|
||||
misreading of Smith v. Maryland); Orin Kerr, My (Mostly Critical) Thoughts on the August 2013
|
||||
FISC Opinion on Section 215, The Volokh Conspiracy (Sep. 17, 2013, 7:39 PM),
|
||||
http://www.volokh.com/2013/09/17/thoughts-august-2013-fisc-opinion-section-215 (explaining
|
||||
that on question of relevance, the Court "refers to an earlier [secret] decision. . . then just
|
||||
concludes[.]").
|
||||
|
||||
JURISDICTION
|
||||
|
||||
The FISC is an Article III court established by Congress, Misc. 13-02 at 4, with
|
||||
"supervisory power over its own records and files." Nixon v. Warner Commc'ns Inc., 435 U.S.
|
||||
589, 598 (1978). In particular, this Court has held that that it has "jurisdiction in the first instance
|
||||
|
||||
5
|
||||
|
||||
to adjudicate a claim of right to the court's very own records and files." In re Motion for Release
|
||||
of Court Records, 526 F. Supp. 2d 484, 487 (FISA Ct. 2007); accord Misc. 13-02 at 11-12 (FISC
|
||||
not precluded by FISC Rules from adjudicating "claim of right' to access 'its very own records
|
||||
and files" or "requests for discretionary publication," at least where “non-parties . . . have
|
||||
sufficient information to make reasonably concrete, rather than abstract arguments in favor of
|
||||
publication"). As detailed below, movant has concrete arguments for publication under both a
|
||||
claim of right and as a discretionary request. Accordingly, the Court has jurisdiction.
|
||||
|
||||
ARGUMENT
|
||||
I. MOVANT HAS STANDING UNDER ARTICLE III TO SEEK THE RELIEF
|
||||
REQUESTED
|
||||
|
||||
Standing is "[o]ne element of the case or controversy requirement." Clapper v. Amnesty
|
||||
Int'l USA, 133 S. Ct. 1138, 1146 (2013) (quoting Raines v. Byrd, 529 U.S. 811, 818 (1997)). To
|
||||
establish standing under Article III, a party invoking federal jurisdiction must demonstrate an
|
||||
injury that is "concrete, particularized, and actual or imminent; fairly traceable to the challenged
|
||||
action; and redressable by a favorable ruling." Clapper, 133 S. Ct. at 1147; accord Lujan v.
|
||||
Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 560-61 (1992) (three "irreducible" elements of standing are
|
||||
"injury-in-fact," "causal connection . . . [to] conduct complained of," and likelihood of
|
||||
redressability).
|
||||
|
||||
Movant has standing to seek the publication of the FISC records. Movant's First
|
||||
Amendment right of access is violated by the continued withholding of these records from the
|
||||
public, which is an “actual, rather than imminent" injury. Misc. 13-02 at 4-5. "Nor is there any
|
||||
real question that this claimed injury is fairly traceable to the government's decision" to withhold
|
||||
them or "that it would be redressed by this Court's directing that those opinions be published."
|
||||
Id. Federal courts have found that news media entities have standing to challenge the closure of
|
||||
|
||||
6
|
||||
|
||||
court records and proceedings. See, e.g., In re Dow Jones & Co., Inc., 842 F.2d 603, 607-08 (2nd
|
||||
Cir. 1988) (news agencies have standing because they are "potential recipients of speech" of
|
||||
underlying closed court proceeding); see also N.Y. Civil Liberties Union v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.,
|
||||
684 F.3d 286, 294-95 (2d Cir. 2012) (“[O]nly a perceptible impairment of an organization's
|
||||
activities is necessary for there to be an injury in fact.").
|
||||
|
||||
Moreover, as this Court found in Misc. 13-02, an entity suffers a sufficiently concrete
|
||||
injury so as to confer standing if it demonstrates "active participation" in the public debate over
|
||||
the matters at issue. Misc. 13-02 at 8-9 (finding that the ACLU had standing to move to unseal a
|
||||
FISC opinion). In such a situation, a movant asserts an injury-in-fact, not simply a "generalized
|
||||
grievance[]," which would be insufficient to confer standing. Id. at 6 (quoting Fed. Election
|
||||
Comm'n v. Akins, 524 U.S. 11, 23-24 (1998)).
|
||||
|
||||
As a Pulitzer-Prize-winning press organization that routinely cover matters of privacy
|
||||
and Internet policy, movant has reported extensively on the government's surveillance efforts.
|
||||
See Declaration of Richard Tofel ("Tofel Decl.”) ¶¶ 4-7. This reporting includes a discussion of
|
||||
the asserted justification for the bulk collection of metadata. See id. ¶ 8. The withholding of FISC
|
||||
opinions that pass on these justifications hinders movant's abilities to fully explain the
|
||||
government's actions to the public. Id. ¶ 9. This is a concrete injury that goes to the heart of
|
||||
movant's organizational activities. Such a showing is more than sufficient to confer standing.
|
||||
|
||||
II. THERE ARE NO KNOWN COMITY CONCERNS THAT SERVE AS A BAR TO
|
||||
THE CONSIDERATION OF THIS MOTION
|
||||
|
||||
This Court also has no prudential barriers to ruling on its motion. In Misc. 13-02, the
|
||||
Court, citing comity concerns and the first-to-file rule, declined to consider the motions to unseal
|
||||
that pertained to FISC opinions that were the subject of ongoing FOIA litigation to which the
|
||||
|
||||
7
|
||||
|
||||
movant was a party. Misc. 13-02 at 12-16. Movant here is not a party to any existing related
|
||||
FOIA litigation.³
|
||||
|
||||
III. THE FIRST AMENDMENT COMPELS THE RELEASE OF THE COURT'S
|
||||
OPINIONS
|
||||
|
||||
A. There is a First Amendment Right of Access to Judicial Opinions
|
||||
|
||||
The Supreme Court has recognized that the public has a First Amendment right of access
|
||||
to many judicial proceedings. See Richmond Newspapers Inc. v. Virginia, 448 U.S. 555, 564-73
|
||||
(1980); Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court, 457 US 596, 603-05 (1982); see also Brown &
|
||||
Williamson Tobacco Corp. v. FTC, 710 F.2d 1165, 1177 (6th Cir. 1983) (explaining that the
|
||||
public nature of legal principles and decisions is a "fundamental feature of the American judicial
|
||||
system," with roots in "the English common law, the American constitutional system, and the
|
||||
notion of 'the consent of the governed'").
|
||||
|
||||
Following the Richmond Newspapers line of cases, courts employ the two-step
|
||||
"experience and logic" test to determine whether there is a right of public access to a category of
|
||||
judicial proceedings: "First, because a tradition of accessibility implies the favorable judgment of
|
||||
experiences, we have considered whether the place and process have historically been open to
|
||||
the press and general public." Press-Enter. Co. v. Superior Court, 478 U.S. 1, 8 (1986) (Press-
|
||||
Enter. II) (citations and internal quotation marks omitted). "Second, in this setting the Court has
|
||||
traditionally considered whether public access plays a significant positive role in the functioning
|
||||
of the particular process in question." Id.
|
||||
|
||||
³ Movant's counsel, Electronic Frontier Foundation, is a party to FOIA litigation pertaining to
|
||||
legal authority upon which the Department of Justice and National Security Agency base their
|
||||
interpretation of Section 215. See Status Report, Elec. Frontier Found. v. U.S. Dep't of Justice,
|
||||
No. 4:11-cv-05221 (N.D. Cal. Sep. 04, 2013), ECF No. 63. It does not appear that the FISC
|
||||
opinion sought by this motion would be responsive to that FOIA request or otherwise subject to
|
||||
that FOIA litigation. Id. at 2.
|
||||
|
||||
8
|
||||
|
||||
This Court has at least twice been faced with a claimed First Amendment right of access
|
||||
to its opinions. See In re Motion for Release of Court Records, 526 F. Supp. 2d at 484; Misc. 13-
|
||||
02. In the first case, the Court held that whatever the general American legal tradition of
|
||||
openness in judicial proceedings, the FISC itself had no such tradition that could meet the
|
||||
experience test. In re Motion for Release of Court Records, 526 F. Supp. 2d at 492-93 ("[T]he
|
||||
FISC has never held a public hearing in its history, and a total of two opinions have been
|
||||
released to the public in nearly three decades of operation. During that period, the FISC has
|
||||
issued literally thousands of classified orders to which the public has had no access."). In the
|
||||
second, the Court was asked to reconsider this holding but instead granted the movant's request
|
||||
without reaching the merits of the First Amendment argument. Misc. 13-02 at 17.
|
||||
|
||||
However, it is now clear both that experience favors finding a right of access, and that the
|
||||
FISC's position with regard to the general tradition of openness has changed. What is more,
|
||||
these changes emphasize the logic in finding a right of access.
|
||||
|
||||
1. Experience
|
||||
|
||||
The experience prong is satisfied here because there is an unbroken history of Article III
|
||||
court opinions being public. Lowenschuss v. West Pub. Co., 542 F.2d 180, 185 (3d Cir. 1976)
|
||||
("[U]nder our system of jurisprudence the judiciary has the duty of publishing and disseminating
|
||||
its decisions."); Brown & Williamson, 710 F.2d at 1177 (opinions and records are presumptively
|
||||
public because "court records often provide important, sometimes the only, bases or explanations
|
||||
for a court's decision").
|
||||
|
||||
⁴ The Court also rejected the argument that a narrower subset of its opinions, those of "broad
|
||||
legal significance," should qualify for the experience test. In re Motion for Release, 526 F. Supp.
|
||||
2d at 493.
|
||||
|
||||
9
|
||||
|
||||
The experience prong does not require a tradition of openness dating back to the
|
||||
ratification of the Constitution. See Press-Enter. II, 478 U.S. at 10-12 (relying on post-Bill of
|
||||
Rights history); Applications of Nat'l Broad. Co., Inc. v. Presser, 828 F.2d 340, 344 (6th Cir.
|
||||
1987) (finding First Amendment right of access while reviewing history from 1924-1984).
|
||||
Indeed, even a very recent tradition of openness may be sufficient. See Detroit Free Press v.
|
||||
Ashcroft, 303 F.3d 681, 703 (6th Cir. 2004) (finding that a "brisk evolution" in pattern of
|
||||
openness of deportation proceedings satisfied the experience test). This is especially the case
|
||||
where "the beneficial effects of access to that process are overwhelming and uncontradicted." Id.
|
||||
at 701; see also United States v. Simone, 14 F.3d 833, 842 (3d Cir. 1994) (finding First
|
||||
Amendment right of access despite no history on point); Cal-Almond, Inc. v. U.S. Dep't of
|
||||
Agric., 960 F.2d 105, 109 (9th Cir. 1992) (finding tradition of public access is reflected in
|
||||
current statutes).
|
||||
|
||||
The FISC is an Article III court issuing judicial opinions based on the "directive force of
|
||||
precedents," and is therefore part of the long tradition of public dissemination of judicial
|
||||
opinions. Lowenschuss, 542 F.2d at 185. That the FISC is a different type of Article III court
|
||||
than, for example, the federal district courts, is not relevant. The experience test looks not "to the
|
||||
particular practice of any one jurisdiction, but instead to the experience in that type or kind of
|
||||
hearing throughout the United States." El Vocero de P.R. v. Puerto Rico, 508 U.S. 147, 150
|
||||
(1993) (per curiam) (quotation marks omitted). As the Third Circuit recently found, even the
|
||||
government's description of a proceeding as a type that has been traditionally closed to the
|
||||
public, such as an arbitration, is not dispositive of the experience test. Del. Coal. for Open Gov't
|
||||
v. Strine, No. 1-11-cv-01015, slip op. at 18 (3d Cir. Oct. 23, 2013). Thus, the right of access
|
||||
applies to a government-sponsored arbitration because it bears important hallmarks of a court
|
||||
|
||||
10
|
||||
|
||||
proceeding and is "deeply rooted in the way the judiciary functions in a democratic society." Id.
|
||||
at 18.
|
||||
|
||||
Even if this Court were correct in stating that the court should look to the FISC's
|
||||
particular tradition rather than the tradition of Article III courts in general, recent experience
|
||||
shows a "brisk evolution" in the openness of FISC opinions. Indeed, the tradition of openness of
|
||||
the FISC opinions is much different than that encountered in 2007, when the FISC rejected the
|
||||
existence of a First Amendment right of access. The number of opinions available to the public
|
||||
since 2007 has multiplied many times over.⁵
|
||||
|
||||
In sum, the experience test favors finding a right of access both with regard to the general
|
||||
tradition of openness of judicial opinions and in regard to the FISC's recent moves to release far
|
||||
more material publicly than ever before.
|
||||
|
||||
2. Logic
|
||||
|
||||
Similarly, the release of the FISC opinions sought by movant will serve a "significant
|
||||
positive role in the functioning of the particular process in question." Press-Enter. II, 478 U.S. at
|
||||
8-9. The Supreme Court has explained that the logic test looks to the benefits that public access
|
||||
to the proceeding or materials would confer, such as "enhanc[ing] both the basic fairness of the
|
||||
|
||||
⁵ At least eight FISC opinions have been made available to the public since 2007, including four
|
||||
in 2013 alone. Many other orders and filings to the court are also now publicly available. See,
|
||||
e.g., U.S. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court Public Filings,
|
||||
http://www.uscourts.gov/uscourts/courts/fisc/index.html (last visited October 8, 2013) (featuring
|
||||
memorandum opinions in case numbers BR 13-158, 13-109, Misc. 13-02, and Misc. 13-01 as
|
||||
well as additional orders and filings); Redacted, 2012 WL 9189263 (FISA Ct. Aug. 24, 2012)
|
||||
(memorandum opinion); Redacted, 2011 WL 10945618 (FISA Ct. Oct. 3, 2011) (memorandum
|
||||
opinion); Office of the Dir. of Nat'l Intelligence, IC on the Record, DNI Clapper Declassifies
|
||||
Intelligence Community Documents Regarding Collection Under Section 501 of the Foreign
|
||||
Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) (Sep. 10, 2013),
|
||||
http://icontherecord.tumblr.com/post/60867560465/dni-clapper-declassifies-intelligence-
|
||||
community (featuring orders and filings from 2006-2009 and supplemental opinions in case
|
||||
numbers 08-13 and 09-15).
|
||||
|
||||
11
|
||||
|
||||
criminal trial and the appearance of fairness so essential to public confidence in the system." Id.
|
||||
In the criminal context, a public trial can have "therapeutic value,” serving as an outlet for
|
||||
"community concern, hostility, and emotion.” Richmond Newspapers, 448 U.S. at 569; Detroit
|
||||
Free Press, 303 F.3d at 704. Perhaps even more important, public access to judicial proceedings
|
||||
ensures accuracy and fairness in the process. Richmond Newspapers, 448 U.S. at 592 (citing In
|
||||
re Oliver, 333 U.S. 257, 270 (1948)).
|
||||
|
||||
This Court has already recognized the benefits of public release of its opinions construing
|
||||
Section 215 in language that closely parallels the purposes of the logic test:
|
||||
|
||||
"Publication of FISC opinions relating to this provision would contribute to an
|
||||
informed public debate. Congressional amici emphasize the value of public
|
||||
information and debate in representing their constituents and discharging their
|
||||
legislative responsibilities. Publication would also assure citizens of the integrity
|
||||
of this Court's proceedings."
|
||||
|
||||
Misc. 13-02 at 16-17. Publication has especially clear benefits where, as here, the opinions at
|
||||
issue contain foundational legal analysis, including interpretation of public statutes and the
|
||||
Constitution itself. As public debate over FISA and Section 215 has grown, commentators have
|
||||
suggested that the FISC's classified opinions are leading to a de facto "secret body of case law"
|
||||
interpreting the Fourth Amendment. Orin Kerr, Hints and Questions About the Secret Fourth
|
||||
Amendment Rulings of the FISA Court, Volokh Conspiracy (July 7, 2013, 1:37 AM),
|
||||
http://www.volokh.com/2013/07/07/hints-and-questions-about-the-secret-fourth-amendment-
|
||||
rulings-of-the-fisa-court. Similar questions exist about the FISC's "circuit"-specific
|
||||
interpretation of relevance. Jennifer Valentino DeVries & Siobhan Gorman, Secret Court's
|
||||
Redefinition of 'Relevant' Empowered Vast NSA Data-Gathering, Wall St. J. (July 8, 2013, 3:13
|
||||
AM), http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323873904578571893758853344.html.
|
||||
In this regard, the previous release of the Section 215 opinion can only be seen as a half-
|
||||
|
||||
12
|
||||
|
||||
measure, since an informed public cannot yet read these foundational interpretations for itself.
|
||||
See Hicklin Engineering, LC v. Bartell, 439 F. 3d 346 (7th Cir. 2006) (“The political branches of
|
||||
government claim legitimacy by election, judges by reason. Any step that withdraws an element
|
||||
of the judicial process from public view makes the ensuing decision look more like fiat and
|
||||
requires rigorous justification."); Brown & Williamson, 710 F.2d at 1177 n.6 ("Long ago Locke
|
||||
emphasized the need for 'promulgated standing laws'—'established, settled, known laws
|
||||
received and allowed by common consent'.... They would not 'put a force into the magistrate's
|
||||
hands to execute his unlimited will arbitrarily upon them.") (quoting Locke, Treatise of Civil
|
||||
Government §§ 124, 136-37 (1690)).
|
||||
|
||||
Finally, at this point, it can hardly be contended that the benefits of disclosure are
|
||||
outweighed by the harm of a decreased flow of information and an avoidance of judicial review.
|
||||
Cf. In re Motion for Release, 526 F. Supp. 2d at 496 ("The greater risk of declassification and
|
||||
disclosure over Executive branch objections would chill the government's interactions with the
|
||||
Court.... [G]overnment officials might choose to conduct a search or surveillance without
|
||||
FISC approval where the need for such approval is unclear.") After widespread reporting of
|
||||
unauthorized disclosures and repeated discussion by public officials of the government's legal
|
||||
authority for bulk collection of metadata, the cat is out of the bag. Because release of the
|
||||
opinions sought is in keeping with the tradition of Article III courts in general and the FISC's
|
||||
evolving practice in specific, and because release would enhance public debate and increase this
|
||||
Court's legitimacy, the Court should find that a First Amendment right of access exists.
|
||||
|
||||
B. The First Amendment Permits the Withholding of Only Those Portions of
|
||||
the Opinion Found Necessary to Protect National Security
|
||||
|
||||
Although the right is not unbounded, "[t]he First Amendment presumes that there is a
|
||||
right of access to proceedings and documents" that meet the experience and logic test. Grove
|
||||
|
||||
13
|
||||
|
||||
Fresh Distributors, Inc. v. Everfresh Juice Co., 24 F.3d 893, 897 (7th Cir. 1994). Once the right
|
||||
applies, the documents sought are presumptively open unless the court finds that four criteria
|
||||
support their retention: (1) There is an "overriding interest" supporting the retention of the
|
||||
records, (2) that this retention is no broader than necessary to protect that interest, (3) that no
|
||||
reasonable alternatives to the retention exist, and (4) this finding is supported by sufficiently
|
||||
specific findings. Press-Enter. Co. v. Superior Court, 464 U.S. 501, 510 (1984) (Press-Enter. I).
|
||||
Thus, the burden is on the government to demonstrate that retention "is essential to preserve
|
||||
higher values," based on a non-conclusory showing of a "substantial probability" of harm to the
|
||||
interest asserted. Press-Enter. II, 478 U.S. at 13-14, 15.
|
||||
|
||||
With the growing record of now-public FISC opinions, the government cannot contend
|
||||
that it has an overriding interest in withholding the opinions sought. The government has pointed
|
||||
to the recently publicized Section 215 opinion as proof of its commitment to increasing
|
||||
transparency and assuring citizens that it is working within the law. Office of the Dir. of Nat'l
|
||||
Intelligence, IC on the Record, Release of Previously Classified August 29, 2013 Foreign
|
||||
Intelligence
|
||||
Surveillance
|
||||
Court Opinion (Sep. 17, 2013, 4:58 PM),
|
||||
http://icontherecord.tumblr.com/post/61526105674/release-of-previously-classified-august-29-
|
||||
2013 ("The opinion affirms that the bulk telephony metadata collection is both lawful and
|
||||
constitutional.") It would therefore be incongruous to maintain that the Section 215 opinion can
|
||||
be released but that the very legal authorities relied on to reach this conclusion are somehow
|
||||
subject to a more compelling need for secrecy. Of course, the Court can redact those portions of
|
||||
an opinion for which the government can meet its burden of showing a compelling interest.
|
||||
Press-Enter. II, 478 U.S. at 13 (specific showing required); United States v Rosen, 487 F. Supp.
|
||||
2d 703, 716 (E.D. Va. 2007) (redacting classified information requires specific showing even in
|
||||
|
||||
14
|
||||
|
||||
national security context). The Court has already ordered such a review in the context of
|
||||
opinions interpreting Section 215, Misc. 13-02 at 18 (requiring government to submit “proposed
|
||||
redactions”), and the finding of a First Amendment right of access to the opinions in this case
|
||||
should only strengthen the necessity of such a review here.
|
||||
|
||||
IV. ALTERNATIVELY, THE COURT SHOULD EXERCISE ITS DISCRETION
|
||||
TO RELEASE THE OPINIONS SOUGHT
|
||||
|
||||
Even if a First Amendment right of access does not exist, this Court instead may rely on
|
||||
its supervisory powers over its own records to publish the opinions sought by movant. Nixon,
|
||||
435 U.S. at 598; In re Motion for Release, 526 F. Supp. 2d at 487. In addition, FISC Rule 62(a)
|
||||
gives the Court "discretion to direct publication sua sponte." Misc. 13-02 at 11; FISC Rule 62(a).
|
||||
Given the Court's previous decision to invoke Rule 62(a) to allow publication of those Section
|
||||
215 opinions not at issue in other litigation, Misc. 13-02 at 17, movant respectfully request that
|
||||
the Court similarly use its discretion to allow publication of the opinions that form the legal
|
||||
authority for the now-public Section 215 opinion.
|
||||
|
||||
Movant's argument for publication is specific to the circumstances and aimed at
|
||||
furthering an already lively public debate. See Misc. 13-02 at 12 (where non-party to FISC
|
||||
proceeding can make "reasonably concrete, rather than abstract, arguments in favor of
|
||||
publication,” FISC may consider publication under Rule 62(a)). Movant does not seek release of
|
||||
unspecified or random FISC opinions, but only those cited and centrally relied on for
|
||||
fundamental legal principles in the already public FISC opinion on Section 215. Nor does
|
||||
movant seek disclosure of any properly classified information. Rule 62(a) provides a mechanism
|
||||
for publication of an opinion with “[r]edactions after consultation with the Executive Branch,
|
||||
[that] can be made to exclude such classified materials without distorting the content of the
|
||||
discussion of the statutory and constitutional issues." Order, In re Directives [Redacted]
|
||||
|
||||
15
|
||||
|
||||
Pursuant to Section 105B of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, No. 08-01 at 1 (FISA Ct.
|
||||
Rev. Jan. 12, 2009), available at http://bit.ly/r32r2W; FISC Rule 62(a); see also Misc. 13-02 at
|
||||
17-18 (invoking Rule 62(a) to request that the government "submit proposed redactions" for
|
||||
Section 215 opinions subject to release).
|
||||
|
||||
CONCLUSION
|
||||
|
||||
For the foregoing reasons, movant respectfully requests that this Court unseal the
|
||||
opinions relied on in its recently released Section 215 opinion which provide support for the
|
||||
legality of bulk metadata collection under the Fourth Amendment and under a relevance
|
||||
standard.
|
||||
|
||||
Dated: November 8, 2013
|
||||
|
||||
Respectfully submitted,
|
||||
|
||||
DAVID GREENE
|
||||
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94109
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
|
||||
Counsel for Movant ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
16
|
||||
|
||||
U.S. FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE
|
||||
SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
|
||||
UNITED STATES FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
WASHINGTON, D.C.
|
||||
2013 NOV 12 PM 3:41.
|
||||
LEEANN FLYNN HALL
|
||||
CLERK OF COURT
|
||||
IN RE MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC.
|
||||
FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT RECORDS
|
||||
)
|
||||
Docket No.: 13-09
|
||||
|
||||
DECLARATION OF RICHARD TOFEL
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene
|
||||
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94109
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
|
||||
Counsel for ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
DECLARATION OF RICHARD TOFEL
|
||||
|
||||
I, Richard Tofel, hereby declare:
|
||||
|
||||
1. I am the president of ProPublica, Inc. Prior to becoming president of
|
||||
ProPublica on January 1, 2013, I was ProPublica's founding general manager, from
|
||||
September 2007 through December 2012. The facts contained in the following affidavit are
|
||||
known to me based on my own personal knowledge.
|
||||
|
||||
2. ProPublica, Inc. is a Delaware non-profit corporation and does business as
|
||||
ProPublica.
|
||||
|
||||
3. ProPublica is an independent, non-profit newsroom that produces investigative
|
||||
journalism in the public interest. Our mission is: "To expose abuses of power and betrayals of
|
||||
the public trust by government, business, and other institutions, using the moral force of
|
||||
investigative journalism to spur reform through the sustained spotlighting of wrongdoing."
|
||||
|
||||
4. ProPublica was founded in 2007 and started publishing in 2008. In its five
|
||||
years of publishing, it has been awarded the Pulitzer Prize twice—including the first Pulitzer
|
||||
ever given to an online news organization, in 2010, and the first-ever awarded for material not
|
||||
published in print, in 2011, as well as a host of other journalism prizes, most notably a
|
||||
Peabody Award in 2013.
|
||||
|
||||
1
|
||||
|
||||
5. ProPublica's reporting has included coverage of privacy, surveillance and
|
||||
Internet policy nearly since its beginning. ProPublica started increasing the resources
|
||||
dedicated to these topics in the middle of 2012.
|
||||
|
||||
6. ProPublica has published dozens of investigative pieces on corporate and
|
||||
government surveillance, including:
|
||||
|
||||
* NIST to Review Standards After Cryptographers Cry Foul Over NSA Meddling,
|
||||
Nov. 4, 2013, [REDACTED]
|
||||
|
||||
* Revealed: The NSA's Secret Campaign to Crack, Undermine Internet Security,
|
||||
Sept. 5, 2013, [REDACTED] (in partnership with the Guardian and the
|
||||
New York Times)
|
||||
|
||||
* Claim on "Attacks Thwarted" by NSA Spreads Despite Lack of Evidence, Oct. 23,
|
||||
2013, [REDACTED]
|
||||
|
||||
* How a Telecom Helped the Government Spy on Me, Oct. 3, 2013, [REDACTED]
|
||||
|
||||
* Mass Surveillance in America: A Timeline of Loosening Laws and Practices, June
|
||||
7, 2013, [REDACTED]
|
||||
|
||||
* No Warrant, No Problem: How the Government Can Get Your Digital Data, July
|
||||
31, 2013, [REDACTED]
|
||||
|
||||
2
|
||||
|
||||
government-can-still-get-your-digital-data (originally published December 4,
|
||||
2012)
|
||||
|
||||
7. ProPublica has been collaborating with the Guardian since June of this year
|
||||
(and more recently also with the New York Times), on stories based on documents provided
|
||||
to the Guardian by Edward Snowden, including the story from September 5 above about the
|
||||
National Security Agency weakening national encryption standards. That story led the body
|
||||
that sets encryption standards to announce a total technical review (discussed in the November
|
||||
4 story above).
|
||||
|
||||
8. ProPublica has also reported specifically on the government's justifications for
|
||||
its surveillance programs, including, in the October 23 story referenced above, claims that the
|
||||
collection of telephone "metadata" has helped thwart terror attacks.
|
||||
|
||||
9. The release of the opinions sought by ProPublica in this motion would aid it in
|
||||
its efforts to inform the public about government surveillance by allowing ProPublica to
|
||||
report on and distill the government's stated legal justifications for its readership.
|
||||
|
||||
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed
|
||||
on November 8, 2013, at New York, New York.
|
||||
|
||||
Richard Tofel
|
||||
|
||||
3
|
||||
|
||||
U.S. FOREIGH
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE
|
||||
SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
|
||||
UNITED STATES FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
WASHINGTON, D.C.
|
||||
2013 NOV 12 PM 3:42
|
||||
LEEANN FLYNN HALL
|
||||
CLERK OF COURT
|
||||
IN RE MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC.
|
||||
FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT RECORDS
|
||||
)
|
||||
Docket No.: 13-09
|
||||
|
||||
CERTIFICATION OF BAR MEMBERSHIP AND SECURITY CLEARANCE STATUS
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene
|
||||
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94109
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
|
||||
Counsel for Movant ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
CERTIFICATION OF BAR MEMBERSHIP AND SECURITY CLEARANCE STATUS
|
||||
|
||||
Pursuant to the United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court Rules of
|
||||
Procedure 7(h)(1), 7(i), and 63, ProPublica, Inc. ("Movant") respectfully submits the following
|
||||
information:
|
||||
|
||||
(1) Bar Membership Information
|
||||
|
||||
Undersigned counsel for Movant is a licensed attorney, and a member in good standing
|
||||
of the bars of United States district and circuit courts. See FISC Rule 7(h)(1); FISC Rule 63.
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene is a member, in good standing, of the State Bar of California (Bar
|
||||
No. 160107), and is a member in good standing of the bars of the United States District Courts
|
||||
for the Northern District of California, Southern District of California, and Central District of
|
||||
California, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
|
||||
|
||||
(2) Security Clearance Information
|
||||
|
||||
Neither Movant's officers or employees or Movant's counsel hold security clearances.
|
||||
See FISC Rule 7(i). Because Movant's motion does not seek the release of legitimately classified
|
||||
information, and because the motion itself does not contain classified information, Movant
|
||||
respectfully submits that Movant and its counsel may participate in proceedings on the motion
|
||||
without access to classified information or security clearances. See FISC Rule 63 (requiring
|
||||
counsel only to have "appropriate security clearances").
|
||||
|
||||
Dated: November 8, 2013
|
||||
|
||||
Respectfully submitted,
|
||||
|
||||
DAVID GREENE
|
||||
Electronic Frontier Foundation
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94110
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
Counsel for Movant ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
U.S. FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE
|
||||
SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
|
||||
UNITED STATES FOREIGN
|
||||
INTELLIGENCE SURVEILLANCE COURT
|
||||
WASHINGTON, D.C.
|
||||
2013 NOV 12 PM 3:42
|
||||
LEEANN FLYNN HALL
|
||||
CLERK OF COURT
|
||||
IN RE MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC.
|
||||
FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT RECORDS
|
||||
)
|
||||
Docket No.: 13-09
|
||||
|
||||
CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene
|
||||
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
|
||||
815 Eddy Street
|
||||
San Francisco, CA 94109
|
||||
(415) 436-9333
|
||||
davidg@eff.org
|
||||
|
||||
Counsel for ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
|
||||
|
||||
I HEREBY CERTIFY that true and correct copies of the following:
|
||||
|
||||
* MOTION OF PROPUBLICA, INC. FOR THE RELEASE OF COURT
|
||||
RECORDS
|
||||
|
||||
* DECLARATION OF RICHARD TOFEL
|
||||
|
||||
* CERTIFICATION OF BAR MEMBERSHIP AND SECURITY CLEARANCE
|
||||
STATUS
|
||||
|
||||
have been served this day on the following counsel by Federal Express 2nd Day Air for
|
||||
delivery on Tuesday November 12, 2013:
|
||||
|
||||
Christine Gunning
|
||||
United States Department of Justice
|
||||
Litigation Security Group
|
||||
2 Constitution Square
|
||||
145 N Street NE
|
||||
Suite 2W-115
|
||||
Washington, DC 20530
|
||||
(202) 514-9016
|
||||
|
||||
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the
|
||||
foregoing is true and correct.
|
||||
|
||||
Dated this 8th day of November, 2013.
|
||||
|
||||
David Greene
|
||||
Counsel for Movant ProPublica, Inc.
|
||||
|
||||
1
|
||||
27
data/FOIA/FISC_-_br13-09-motion-131112/metadata.json
Normal file
27
data/FOIA/FISC_-_br13-09-motion-131112/metadata.json
Normal file
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
|
|||
{
|
||||
"title": "Motion of ProPublica, Inc. for the Release of Court Records, In re Motion of ProPublica, Inc. for the Release of Court Records, No. Misc. 13-09 (FISA Ct. Nov. 12, 2013).",
|
||||
"type": "foia",
|
||||
"description": "FISC/FISCR Court Filings",
|
||||
"long_description": "",
|
||||
"tags": [],
|
||||
"document": {
|
||||
"creator": "FISC",
|
||||
"date_created": "2013-11-12",
|
||||
"classification": [],
|
||||
"dissemination": [],
|
||||
"programs": [],
|
||||
"countries": [],
|
||||
"people": []
|
||||
},
|
||||
"publication": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"publisher": "ACLU,EFF",
|
||||
"date_published": "2013-11-12",
|
||||
"link": "https://www.fisc.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/Misc%2013-09%20Motion-2.pdf",
|
||||
"reporters": [],
|
||||
"contributors": []
|
||||
}
|
||||
],
|
||||
"pdf_sha256": "ad13eacc9afae27ae7d6ebc87624244f0a7c3cf0d6b854a091412267e50d1d19",
|
||||
"pages": 30
|
||||
}
|
||||
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue