first commit

This commit is contained in:
libroot 2026-11-19 04:39:11 +02:00
commit 0d90363116
Signed by: libroot
GPG key ID: 2AC68C029EBE9ACE
6510 changed files with 679146 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,271 @@
UNITED STATES FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE
SURVEILLANCE COURT
IN RE MOTION FOR CONSENT TO DISCLOSURE
OF COURT RECORDS OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE,
A DETERMINATION OF THE EFFECT OF THE
COURT'S RULES ON STATUTORY ACCESS RIGHTS
Docket No. MISC.
13-01
MOTION OF THE ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
FOR CONSENT TO DISCLOSURE OF COURT RECORDS OR, IN
THE ALTERNATIVE, A DETERMINATION OF THE EFFECT OF
THE COURT'S RULES ON STATUTORY ACCESS RIGHTS
DAVID L. SOBEL
Electronic Frontier Foundation
1818 N Street, N. W., Suite 410
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 797-9009
sobel@eff.org
MARK RUMOLD
Electronic Frontier Foundation
454 Shotwell Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
(415) 436-9333
mark@efl.org
Counsel for Electronic Frontier Foundation
Introduction
Pursuant to Rule 6(d) of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court's Rules of
Procedure ("FISC Rules"), the Electronic Frontier Foundation ("EFF") respectfully
moves this Court for entry of an order consenting to the disclosure of certain Court
records, subject to appropriate security procedures or, in the alternative, a determination
that the FISC Rules do not constitute a bar to disclosure of records otherwise subject to
release under the Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"), 5 U.S.C. § 552. While EFF
recognizes that such a request to this Court is unusual, EFF's need for the requested relief
results from a position the U.S. Department of Justice ("DOJ") has advanced in pending
FOIA litigation in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. The
circumstances giving rise to this motion are set forth below.
Background
In July 2012, EFF filed a FOIA request with DOJ requesting, among other
records, any "written opinion or order" of this Court in which the Court held government
surveillance conducted under the FISA Amendments Act, Pub. L. 110-261, 122 Stat.
2436 (2008), "was unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment" or had "circumvented the
spirit of the law." Complaint ¶ 12 (Dkt. No. 1). After DOJ failed to release the
requested records within the statutorily-mandated timeframe, EFF filed suit in the United
States District Court for the District of Columbia on August 30, 2012.
By letter dated January 3, 2013, DOJ initially informed EFF that it had located
records, including a FISC opinion, responsive to EFF's request. Memorandum of Points
In this motion, all citations to docket entries are to EFF v. Dep't of Justice, No. 12-
1441-ABJ (D.D.C. filed Aug. 30, 2012).
2
and Authorities in Support of the Dep't of Justice's Motion for Summary Judgment
("DOJ Mem.") (Dkt. No. 11-1) (attached hereto as Exhibit 1) at 8-9. The agency
indicated that the records were being withheld in full under Exemptions 1 and 3 of the
FOIA. Id.
On April 1, 2013, DOJ moved for summary judgment in the district court. The
agency again acknowledged that it was withholding a FISC opinion responsive to EFF's
request -- an 86-page opinion issued on October 3, 2011.2 Declaration of Mark Bradley
("Bradley Decl."), ¶ 5 (Dkt. No. 11-3) (attached hereto as Exhibit 2). DOJ claimed in its
motion that, independent of any exemption to FOIA, the FISC Rules bar the agency from
disclosing any part of the responsive opinion in response to a FOIA request. See DOJ
Mem. at 11-15. Specifically, DOJ asserted that
FISC opinions and orders are subject to strict security procedures set forth
in the FISC Rules of Procedure. See 50 U.S.C. § 1803(c) (providing that
"record[s] of proceedings under this chapter, including applications made
and orders granted, shall be maintained under security measures
established by the Chief Justice in consultation with the Attorney General
and the Director of National Intelligence"). Notwithstanding that, by
statute, the Attorney General as part of his reporting obligations to
Congress is authorized to provide copies of FISC opinions to Congress,
(see 50 U.S.C. § 1871(c)(1)), the FISC Rules of Procedure require that the
government "contemporaneously notify the Court in writing whenever it
provides copies of Court records to Congress and must include in the
notice a list of the documents provided." FISC R. P. 62(c)(1). Otherwise,
the FISC Rules of Procedure do not authorize the release of court
opinions by the Department. See FISC R. P. 62. Rather, opinions may be
released publicly only if ordered published sua sponte by the authoring
judge or upon motion by a party requesting publication[.]
Id. at 14 (citations omitted; emphasis added). DOJ flatly asserted that "[p]ursuant to the
FISC Rules of Procedure, the Department is prohibited from disclosing [the requested
2 A second, redacted version of the FISC Opinion, which was produced for Congress,
was also determined to be responsive to EFF's request.
3
material] publicly," and that "the Department has no discretion over the release of FISC
orders and accordingly is not 'improperly withholding [them]." Id. at 15 (citations and
footnote omitted). The agency's declarant stated unequivocally that "FISC rules do not
permit the Government to release FISC opinions to a FOIA requester or any other
member of the public without a FISC order." Bradley Decl. ¶ 8, n.2.
On April 24, 2013, EFF filed a motion in the district court to stay proceedings in
the pending FOIA matter on the ground that such a stay was warranted "to definitively
resolve the interplay between the FISC's procedural rules, FOIA, and the release of the
FISC opinions at issue in [the district court] case," Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion to Stay
Proceedings (Dkt. No. 12) at 1-2, and noted that "[t]he FISC is uniquely able to opine on
the application of its own rules, and should clearly be afforded an opportunity to do so
before this [the district court] proceeds," id. at 3. DOJ indicated that it did not oppose
EFF's motion, and the district court granted the motion in a minute order issued later that
day.
Argument
1. The Court has jurisdiction to entertain this motion. On one previous occasion,
this Court was called upon to consider its authority to render a determination concerning
the potential disclosure of its orders and opinions. In 2007, the American Civil Liberties
Union ("ACLU") filed a motion with the Court seeking release of certain FISC records,
including orders issued by the Court. In re Release of Court Records, 526 F. Supp. 2d
484 (Foreign Intel. Surv. Ct. 2007). The government opposed the ACLU's motion,
asserting, inter alia, that "the Court lacks jurisdiction over the motion." Id. at 485. The
Court disagreed, noting that "it would be quite odd if the FISC did not have jurisdiction
4
in the first instance to adjudicate a claim of right to the court's very own records and
files." Id. at 487 (footnote omitted). The Court held that "the FISC rules do not preclude
the filing of [the] motion by the ACLU," and that "[f]urthermore, this Court's inherent
power over its records supplies the authority to consider a claim of legal right to release
of those records . . . ." Id.
2. The FISC Rules do not bar disclosure under FOIA. Contrary to DOJ's
assertion in the district court, the FISC Rules, in and of themselves, in no way prohibit
disclosure of the records EFF seeks through its FOIA request. As an initial matter, the
circumstances present here are clearly distinguishable from those the Court confronted
when it considered the ACLU's motion in 2007. The ACLU asserted that "under the
First Amendment and the common law, the public has a qualified right of access to the
records in question," and sought entry of an order releasing the material on those
grounds. In re Release of Court Records, 526 F. Supp, at 485. The Court rejected that
argument for reasons not pertinent here, but noted that, "[o]f course, nothing in this
decision forecloses the ACLU from pursuing whatever remedies may be available to it in
a district court through a FOIA request addressed to the Executive Branch." Id. at 497.
While the Court acknowledged the option of "making its own release decisions about
classified documents . . . [by] conduct[ing] a review under the same standards as a district
court would in FOIA litigation," it concluded "there would be no point in this Court's
merely duplicating the judicial review that the ACLU, and anyone else, can obtain by
5
submitting a FOIA request to the Department of Justice for these same records." Id. at
496 n.32.3
Here, EFF simply seeks to pursue its statutory right of access under FOIA in the
manner this Court previously described. Rather than ask the Court to "mak[e] its own
release decisions about classified documents," EFF requested access to copies of the
Court's opinions in the possession of the Executive Branch. In response, DOJ has
represented to the district court that "[p]ursuant to the FISC Rules of Procedure, the
Department is prohibited from disclosing [the requested material] publicly," and that "the
Department has no discretion over the release of FISC orders and accordingly is not
'improperly withholding [them]." Def. Mem. at 15 (citations and footnote omitted).
DOJ specifically cites FISC Rule 62(a), which provides:
Publication of Opinions. The Judge who authored an order, opinion, or
other decision may sua sponte or on motion by a party request that it be
published. Upon such request, the Presiding Judge, after consulting with
other Judges of the Court, may direct that an order, opinion or other
3 In its opposition to the ACLU's motion, the government agreed that FOIA provided the
appropriate vehicle through which to seek disclosure of this Court's records:
Under FOIA, the ACLU cannot ask this Court for its orders because FOIA
applies only to Executive Branch agency records. The ACLU can use
FOIA, however, to seek access to FISC orders and Government briefs in
the Executive Branch's possession. The FOIA process, which combines
an initial review and decision by the Executive Branch on the release and
withholding of information with Judicial Branch review in an adversary
and public proceeding, is the proper means for the ACLU to seek records
of this Court's proceedings from the Executive Branch. Moreover, FOIA's
judicial remedies must be sought only in district court, not in this Court.
Instead of following the FOIA process that Congress carefully laid out, the
ACLU has improperly attempted an end run around FOIA by filing this
motion.
Opposition to the American Civil Liberties Union's Motion for Release of Court
Records, In re Motion for Release of Court Records (Foreign Intel. Surv. Ct. Misc. 07-
01), at 5 (citation omitted).
6
decision be published. Before publication, the Court may, as appropriate,
direct the Executive Branch to review the order, opinion, or other decision
and redact it as necessary to ensure that properly classified information is
appropriately protected pursuant to Executive Order 13526 (or its
successor).
EFF respectfully submits that while FISC Rule 62(a) provides one means of seeking
disclosure of FISC records, it in no way purports to be the exclusive means of doing so.
Indeed, this Court has explicitly recognized that "anyone" can obtain judicial review of a
government decision to withhold copies of this Court's records "by submitting a FOIA
request to the Department of Justice for these same records." In re Release of Court
Records, 526 F. Supp. at 496 n.32.
When the ACLU sought an order from this Court seeking the release of FISC
records, the government complained that the request amounted to an attempted "end run
around FOIA." Now, in the face of EFF's effort to seek disclosure of FISC material in
the government's possession under FOIA (following this Court's explicit guidance), DOJ
asserts that this Court's rules somehow bar release and, in effect, divest the district court
of its jurisdiction to consider the matter. EFF submits that the government cannot have it
both ways. The argument DOJ seeks to advance in the district court would, if accepted,
impose a "Catch-22" preventing any judicial review of access rights to this Court's
materials. To avoid that result. EFF respectfully requests entry of an order in which this
Court notes its consent (or lack of opposition) to the disclosure of the material EFF seeks
should such material be found to be non-exempt under the provisions of FOIA, subject to
any security procedures the Court deems appropriate. In the alternative, EFF requests a
determination that the FISC rules do not prohibit disclosure of the requested material in a
7
manner that would supersede a judicial determination that such material is subject to
disclosure under FOIA.
Conclusion
For the foregoing reasons, EFF's motion should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
David Sobel /s/
DAVID L. SOBEL
Electronic Frontier Foundation
1818 N Street, N.W., Suite 410
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 797-9009
sobel@eff.org
Mark Rumold /s/
MARK RUMOLD
Electronic Frontier Foundation
454 Shotwell Street
San Francisco, CA 94110
(415) 436-9333
mark@eff.org
Counsel for Electronic Frontier Foundation
8
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that copies of the foregoing motion have been served on
the following counsel this 21st day of May, 2013, in the manner indicated:
By e-mail:
JACQUELINE COLEMAN SNEAD
Senior Counsel
United States Department of Justice
Civil Division, Federal Programs Branch
20 Massachusetts Ave, NW
Washington, D.C. 20530
E-mail: Jacqueline.Snead@usdoj.gov
By overnight delivery:
CHRISTINE GUNNING
United States Department of Justice
Litigation Security Group
2 Constitution Square
145 N Street NE
Suite 2W-115
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 514-9016
9
Mark Rumold

View file

@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
{
"title": "Motion of the Electronic Frontier Foundation for Consent to Disclosure of Court Records or, in the Alternative, a Determination of the Effect of the Court's Rules of Statutory Access Rights, In re Motion for Consent to Disclosure of Court Records or, in the Alternative, A Determination of the Effect of the Court's Rules on Statutory Access Rights",
"type": "foia",
"description": "FISC/FISCR Court Filings",
"long_description": "",
"tags": [],
"document": {
"creator": "FISC",
"date_created": "2013-05-21",
"classification": [],
"dissemination": [],
"programs": [],
"countries": [],
"people": []
},
"publication": [
{
"publisher": "ACLU,EFF",
"date_published": "2013-05-21",
"link": "https://donohueintellaw.ll.georgetown.edu/record/34430",
"reporters": [],
"contributors": []
}
],
"pdf_sha256": "36725aa3366920d1b01b66260db868ed7f544b2493ef0f599c4c7e4b68ed80ab",
"pages": 9
}